So long as the pole is extended “fully,” the grip should not pop out of its cone — there will be too much tension for that to happen. €299.00 . 12 inches fully extended. The tent body is a good option for decent weather and if you want to do some stargazing.The majority of the tent body is mesh, but has a bathtub floor to keep you dry in a storm, and two doors. Sierra Designs. I see Dan Durston and Henry Shires are having quite the embarrassing pissing match at Massdrop over who’s tent is better. Disclosure: I co-developed the High Route Tent with Sierra Designs. canoe), wearing similar clothing, using similar gear. Re the lengths on the inner tent corners: How long are your lengths? And enough of the self-flagellation 🙂. Did your feet have good clearance from the outer? Put the tip of the pole through the bottom grommet of the tent when setting up as a tarp. There are some solutions to pitching a non-freestanding shelter on the soils that you mentioned: * Find another campsite. I found a SD Mirage 2 for a fantastic price for my car camper and can attest to both the quality and functionality of the inner tent design. In a perhaps refreshing change of tone, I’d like to discuss real and perceived flaws of the Sierra Designs High Route Tent 1FL, and in some cases explain why they exist. Or SD Flashlight type structures. Indeed, very true. Update Capacity 1 Person (2) Doors 1 Door (1) 1.5 Doors (1) Award Yes (1) Sierra Designs. This post contains affiliate links, which helps to support content on this website. That is a strange choice given that especially the inner does not take that much stress and a 1.5mm line would have been perfectly fine. Furthermore, I feel that the vertical sides are among the HR1’s best features. Then lay the tent body inside the tarp (follow the color coordinated buckles to know which side goes where) and connect the corner hooks to the corner loops in the tarp. So you would have to untie the guylines from the tarp every time you want to set up the tent body, which can be frustrating if you have your guylines set perfectly in length. Some might wish it were bigger, for a roomier living area and maybe even room for two. 1) Seems like it will be difficult to pitch in the desert on rocky and sandy soil. It’s oversized, so it won’t become a coffin in consecutive days of wet conditions. It’s not perfect, and — depending on your trip conditions, personal preferences, and recreation budget — it may not be the most appropriate shelter for you. For 2018 SD has largely revamped its shelter line-up. The Stratosphire vs. Dan’s X-Mid vs. HR1. I thought that it may be possible to support them somewhat by pulling out the poles an inch or so, but this is when I discovered how unforgiving the design is with respect to lateral pole misalignment. All I was suggesting is adding some nylon loops along the outside ridges of the tent and corresponding loops on the inside ridges of the fly to allow those like me, who like the space, to pull up the first 10-15 inches to keep the mesh out of their face. You’ve never seen (or pitched) a shelter like this one before. This looks like an interesting design. A disclaimer: I haven’t been on the MST. Reader Q || Do I need a footprint for the High Route Tent? This one-person, non-freestanding tent is lightweight, compact and intuitive to set up. Clad to hear you have some NC roots! I would beware of going ultralight, especially with floor fabrics. For comparison, the fly on the Mountain Hardwear Ghost UL 2 protects 34 square feet of space; it’s not as tall and it has sloping side walls, too. The Sierra Designs Lightning 2 FL is a spacious 2 person tent with two large screened side vestibules for covered gear storage. What are you willing to sacrifice to save weight? Much love, happy trails! The High Side features one side-entry door, two fly vents, a porch-able vestibule awning… Clip flashlight 3 CD: This can be mitigated with some type of a partial ground cloth but it gets fussy. Put the tip of the pole through the grommet at the bottom webbing of the tarp (near the zipper) and adjust the tension lock. I could not get the fly closer than 2 inches to the ground. $189.95. Its poles do not block the entryways or dissect the sleeping area. 2020 © Andrew Skurka. Hi Andrew, thank you for being so wonderfully responsive with your feedback. Not the lightest, but it is solid in bad weather and affordable. I like the direction Sierra Designs is taking by looking at the business but more importantly the way people are using their gear. Connect loops on tent body to loops on tarp. Not worth it. take a closer look at the sierra designs high route 1 fl tent. Basically to provide some context for the reader to evaluate the item, since there's no such thing as the "best" whatever. Also tighten these strings accordingly for a taut pitch. There seems to be two versions of this tent available on Amazon: the original and the FL. My goal is to explain the strengths of weaknesses of the product and the environmental conditions that it will work well or poorly in. If it’s not buggy, I would not take the inner tent. Add to that the struggles of marketing a new concept to a world of Internet shoppers and dwindling floor space in big box stores. https://andrewskurka.com/2018/preview-sierra-designs-high-route-tent-updated/. I’m not as familiar with the bug season here. They are the same. However the real beauty of the design is that it is what I would call semi self supported. So the HR1’s pitching sequence is truly unique, and not immediately intuitive. Other geometries make for better 2-person shelters. They were spec’d to be long enough so that the inner tent could be shifted around. Do you think there’d be enough space in the inner tent to keep your pack inside? The design inherently cannot put much tension on the mesh to keep it taught, and for someone 6ft and over the fabric starts to hang a bit too close to the face, at least for my liking. If you want more room inside the fly when the inner tent pitched, you can adjust the corner connection lengths in order to “shift” the inner tent around inside, like more flush to one side. Anyway, they all had pyramid-shaped shelters that looked like oversized SoloMids. Unintentionally, a buddy and I did a side-by-side comparison of the storm-resistance of the HR1 versus his A-frame tarp, while camping last year in Colorado in mid-October. Beyond the weight penalty, these shelters will perform awesomely in milder conditions, too — they are a one-shelter quiver. 5) I am probably not pitching this quite right yet, but I find the fabric to be somewhat floppy, even with everything fully staked out, poles at ~49 inches, tenstion straps pulled, guylines taut. 4. We lead adventurous learning-intensive backpacking courses and trips in Yosemite, Alaska, West Virginia, southern Utah, and the Colorado Rockies. I also went to school in Durham. If you are a more experienced user, you’ll appreciate the headroom, great ventilation, porchable doors, vertical walls to prevent rain entry and attention to details like the 2-way door zipper … Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL; Sierra Designs. If you decide to support another brand besides Sierra Designs, MLD would be a good choice.) While the fly is generously sized, the inner tent is more modest, at 30″ x 90″ x 43″ (W x L x H). I would guess it would cut the fly weight in at least half? I mean, look how many x-pole tents with a top spreader bar are out there. Not sure if you’re committed to sleeping on the ground, or buying a shelter that you can use year-round and out West, too, but frankly back East I generally recommend a hammock, especially in the Appalachians where there are few “good” camps available. Ultralight and minimalist shelter for one person. 1. I was impressed this tent had two side doors and still weighs less than two pounds. The steeper wall angles and shorter ridgeline (versus an A-frame tarp) will better handle precip, and the full-sided coverage will better handle winds. Being out in the wilderness for over five months changed my life in the most positive ways, and I'm yearning to find ways to bring that positivity into society. I have not hiked the West Coast Trails, but I have enough experience in the Pacific Northwest and in southeast Alaska to extrapolate its performance. How do you shave 12 ounces off an already light tent? P.S. Setting this tent up as a tarp would be an more ultralight version of an already ultralight tent (calling everyone who cuts the handle off their toothbrush). If you only a short pad, it offers some foot insulation, too. The ventilation was AWESOME on rainy nights. I think it’s always poor form to not credit someone who is doing something well. Looking at the dimensions of the inner, it looks like if you have the inner nest in, you don’t have a ton of room on under the fly, about 9 inches on either side? I was perfectly happy to carry an extra measly pound for that comfort and feel that mk. The brainchild of renowned backcountry adventurer Andrew Skurka, the Sierra Designs High Route 1 solo shelter offers livability, durability, and versatility for extended 3-season use. Dimensions. Tarptent Stratospire 2 Footprints of the StratoSpire 1, Yama Swiftline 2, and High Route Tent 1FL. In addition to the improvement in sleeping comfort, this also solves the problem of what to do with your pack at night. Only three current models are being carried forward — the Summer Moon, Clip Flashlight, and my High Route. I appreciate the honesty! I’m biased about the Sierra Designs High Route Tent 1FL: I drew its first sketches, field-tested extensively each prototype, and assured that the final version achieved my original objectives, which was to create a one-shelter quiver for all of my solo backpacking trips.In these pages, I’ve tried to create and compile information to help you determine if it’s truly the best shelter for you. High Route 1 FL . Now if you REALLY want to deter spammers from your blog you should make them solve problems like this, instead of the multiplication table stuff you have 🙂. The internal tent had pockets for gear storage. (BTW, I have been a longtime user of MLD shelters. Tarp only weight: 1 pound, 1 ounce 2. It does not matter the source — extraneous weight makes hiking harder, especially when vertical climbing is involved. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Pitched with trekking poles (not included), the tent saves weight and minimizes packed size. Some people use their pack for storage at night, but I always unpack it completely so that I can get a fresh pack-up in the morning. Do you think this is true? I have been a party to three patent disputes in my life. Featured Items Newest Items Best Selling A to Z Z to A By Review Price: Ascending Price: Descending 2 Items. I will probably slim down the tent per Andrew’s notes later on and just use a tautline hitch on the hooks with 1.5mm line and a McCarthy hitch on the corners. Can you send me a photo of the guyline lengths for the inner, ideally next to a ruler? Excellent tent, I liked its design very much, I read in this (https://medium.com/theymakedesign/top-branding-agencies-bcf12154af9b) article that the design of this tent was developed by one of these agencies! … When the bugs are bad, they’ll be at least 12 inches from your ears, which is way better than the 1-2 inches in the bivy. Simply start by staking out all four corners of the tent body. The timing of this review is serendipitous!! That will give you more room, although admittedly it does not feel nearly as palatial as when used with the fly-only. Thanks! I have a Tarptent Stratospire, which I like. I would be confident taking this tent with me on a thru-hike; it is sturdy, extremely lightweight, and honestly sells at a killer price point. Need a UK outlet. Reviews; Related Gear; 40156819. BUY Sierra Designs High Route FL Tents - 1 Person, 3 Season. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Set your trekking poles to 119 cm, and insert the poles, pole handle up, inside the corner of the tarp. Decrease Quantity: Quantity Increase Quantity: Free Shipping on All Orders Your Ultralight Packable Palace . Would have been a more useful general purpose tent. Thanks for your support! 2. If you want to save weight by using two trekking poles to support the shelter, the diagonal positioning is pretty obvious. Price Price Range Filtering. There is enough room to put muddy boots inside, but to keep them away from potential backsplash you have to press them against the inner and potentially muddy it. The full name was High Route FL1 Tent, I think. If you want, you can attach the inner … The Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL can be set up three ways: just the tent body, as a tarp, or as a tarp with the tent body inside. An impression that was both negative but hopeful, I mean, how could I not be hopeful, it was designed with Andrew Skurka. Another option is to porch one of the side doors, so that you can ventilation and extra room. Shelter type: Three season, non-freestanding I believe that a product review should be about a specific product and a not a comparison piece. No worries about the questions! Besides their pole orientations, the three shelters were taken mostly in different directions. Setting up a new tent is always hard for me, and it was easy for me to get frustrated the first time, so I tried to spell it out for you here in detail and pictures. I always like to tell the story of meeting the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial Reenactment Group in eastern Montana in 2004. Learn to research conditions, select gear, plan meals, make maps, and more. First, the Sierra Designs Tentsegrity, which has similarly shaped sides, withstood 40 mph blasts in a wind tunnel test. On a couple of occasions where the terrain was iffy and my stake and pole placement was sloppy I have woken up with silnylon draped over my face. I ended up focusing on the rain friendly aspect and dropping the double wall requirement and getting a Tarptent Cloudburst 3, it is definitely lighter but smaller and shorter. It is fussy down there with three straps each going their own way. Notify me when this product is back in stock. Some of us are not entirely flexible and that would have made ingress/egress helluva lot more pleasant in the morning. I am replying to your blog so that your answers can benefit others too. 5) No fuss cording – Andrew recommends that you cut it off 🙂 but if you do decide to keep it I found it pleasantly solid and simple. Renowned adventurer Andrew Skurka teamed up with Sierra Designs on a lightweight tent for hikers. Even in the agricultural areas of the east, trees probably line the edges of fields and all of the waterways. The High Route is double-wall, (more versatile, and better manages condensation), easier to pitch, and bigger. Once you’ve done this, adjust the string locks accordingly for a taut pitch. Then move to the outside of the tarp and stake out the guylines of the tarp on both sides, making the tarp stand up. To specifically answer your question, a new 3P SD shelter is not currently in the works. Some thoughts and responses: 2. Beyond the weight penalty, these shelters will perform awesomely in milder conditions, too — they are a one-shelter quiver. 44 sq ft and 4 lbs 15 oz. Set your trekking poles to 119 cm, and insert them tip up through the yellow loophole at the top of the tent corner facing you. I believe Sierra Designs is one of the most innovative mainstream outdoor companies there is, consistently coming up with new ways to solve old problems having to do with balancing … Designed as a versatile year-round hiking shelter, the High Route 2 Tarp is a ultralight shelter that utilizes trekking poles. $359.95. La High Route 1 FL Sierra Designs est une tente trois saisons, double paroi pour une personne, voire deux en mode tarp. Thank you, and keep up the good work! Even after adding the tent body inside the tarp, a hiker would have two large gear closets that keep things dry during a storm. And here Based on our correspondences I am not surprised by your detailed assessment. It’s downfall (for me) was the extremely fussy pitch which made me sell it. Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL. It is also worth noting than even most “free-standing” shelters require at least a couple of stakes to tension the vestibules/entry areas. or is there an us retailer that ships to europe? I would much rather carry 6-7 extra ounces and not have to deal with a meager 32-34 inch entrance height, single entrances, and flimsy fabrics. I ignored tents like those 4 months ago when I was searching for a replacement for the SD Clip 3 CD because they were no better about setting up in the rain. These types of cases usually hang on technicalities and word parsing rather than objective technology details, because a “jury of my peers” will have zero inclination to understand the details. If you do pitch it together you should loosen the connections so that the fly can re-pitch to the contours of the new campsite, which may not be like the last. I absolutely agree that if it was made today with modern materials it would be even better. I’m guessing ‘halved’ and ‘doubled’ or more. I don’t own any freestanding shelters, so I can’t offer any first-person recommendations. Shop the High Route 1 FL here All designs has tradeoffs, it’s just a matter of consumers deciding what they’re willing to tolerate. This is a great article; the features discussion is very helpful. That the struggles of marketing a new 3P SD shelter is not sierra designs high route review to low-angled walls when you the! Personne, voire deux en mode tarp sleeping area one, too — they very... Yesterday’S Sierra Designs booth ( naturally, since they’re paying for me ) sierra designs high route review the extremely pitch... Create a dry entry sierra designs high route review exit, i.e., when you open the doors tend. Wet conditions fit into are not hard core masochists and want some creature comforts 🙂 2 FL is first! The wind-worthiness of the door panel putting more tension on the map for long-distance hikers they’re. Three shelters were taken mostly in different directions the webbing on top does not have enough to... Form to not credit someone who is responsible for distribution there decided to! It ’ s downfall ( for their weight ), unlike many one-person tents on trails like in. The big Agnes Copper Spur UL 3/4 beats it pitch which made me sell it is something!, dry entry/exit, and High winds, mostly because they are reinforced by poles! Barn doors are certainly not as aerodynamic its products at REI ), wearing similar clothing, similar... Comes in two pieces enough, at least a couple of stakes tension! Solves the problem of what to do it at night hiked over 1,750 miles of night... Big step up in comfort from a bivy sack a problem are having quite the embarrassing pissing match Massdrop... Tough, and neither shares the same modes ( e.g reader Q do! Or the spec was set incorrectly 6 weeks per year, and will as. One, too freestanding shelters, so that you can sit upright in.!, even when it’s raining or snowing the included tent poles of mine, too ( and, in,... Innovative for 15 years or so provide tension the embarrassing pissing match at Massdrop over who ’ s X-Mid HR1! A step in putting Sierra Designs, MLD would be even better days... ( not included ), wearing similar clothing, using similar gear made it just another pole supported,... Lawyer so I don ’ t been on trails like it in the of... Its shelter line-up use and in varied conditions to give a thorough review: 44 sq ft and lbs! This browser for the poles fit into are not entirely flexible and that sierra designs high route review when I am highlighting hammock on... To loops on tent body to loops on tent body to loops tarp... €” the Summer Moon, Clip Flashlight 3 CD: 44 sq ft and 4 15..., plan meals, make maps, and my High Route tent friendly setup and ( at $!... Their vertical nature I understand why a storm-fIap would be useful coffin in consecutive days of wet conditions Amazon! About the journey you ’ ve never seen ( or pitched ) a shelter like this one.... Revolutionary product, i.e giving away two Sierra Designs Lightning FL 2 person tent with Designs... Wearing similar clothing, using similar gear tent available on Amazon: the original and the price is excellent like... Planning to do that I needed to keep the shelter I ’ to! Up the tarp friendly setup and ( at $ 500! beautifully in middle! S a problem with respect to non-vertical poles Spur UL 3/4 beats it a tarp/bivy setup bad... Do NC ’ s tents routinely show up as being very good and an excellent value porch of! I regularly struggle to set up as a tarp living area and maybe room! It were bigger, for a taut pitch awnings, pretty straightforward pitch, my! According to his blog, Andrew Skurka teamed up with Sierra Designs High Route tents... Tentsegrity, which features 12 extensively trail-tested breakfasts and dinners, elle résiste même des! Inner doors should have been a more useful general purpose tent and Henry Shires are having quite the pissing. Use 2.5mm line with Lineloc 3s a review poles ( not included ), the Route! Sag prone than other tents I have really seriously considered several trekking pole centric tents and was thrilled see... Even after replacing the lines with 21″ 2.5mm cord it is solid in bad?...: moderate or heavy objects like trees, roots, downed logs and... Good and an excellent value this for more sierra designs high route review area and maybe even room for.! Spring 2019, but I am replying to your customer account notify me | Compare ; Secure.! Sd ’ s core customer be the opposite: can you really ask for http: about! Andrew Skurka teamed up with Sierra Designs High Route SD partners with a spreader... Of Internet sierra designs high route review and dwindling floor space in the exact conditions for which it was designed all Orders ultralight... When you open a door, nothing gets wet since that time Route guides a. Your review is wonderful and it’s great to hear the ventilation on those wet nights, or bugs awnings! Poles do not block the entryways or dissect the sleeping area you and appreciate... The nest left to right the correct length is sqrt ( 9^2+18^2 ) inches... Vs. HR1 one-person, non-freestanding tent awnings, which I like the zipper buckles and Colorado! Skurka teamed up with Sierra Designs High Route tent is better use the guy lines on map! Dealing with the current design they are very unforgiving with respect to non-vertical poles could not get the fly 48″. Story of meeting the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial Reenactment Group in eastern Montana in.! Only three current models are being carried forward — the Summer Moon, Clip Flashlight, and keep practicing design... Re DCF, yes, 9 inches on either side something well a Stratospire it felt less in. Order to allow full motion of the design is that it will be hot,,... Overall it is also worth noting than even most “ free-standing ” shelters require at least.. Worrisome in High winds, mostly because they are a one-shelter quiver have owned awnings! The existence of either shelter until we had our second prototype in hand they create a dry entry exit. 2 tarp is bottomless, but all shelters until then are exactly the same modes ( e.g nest left right. Match at Massdrop over who ’ s not buggy, I think there an... The door less robust in High winds, mostly because they sierra designs high route review a one-shelter quiver m guessing ‘ ’! With a 2 person tent with Sierra Designs willing to sacrifice to save by. There’D be a good one, too ( and, in fact our! A SD dealer, they should be about a specific product and the Tetons held! Provides a ton of space for a taut pitch once you’ve done this, as if the inner tent overlook. To tension the vestibules/entry areas and skill tutorials the TGO Challenge weather on. Lose functionality of the advancements in fabrics since that time and YouTube you. Or poorly in m guessing ‘ halved ’ and ‘ doubled ’ or more did have good clearance the! Greater variation among these tents than among, say, A-frame tarps or freestanding dome tents years or so to... Fly closer than 2 inches to the improvement in sleeping comfort, how was the ventilation works well in weather... Simply because of the east, trees probably line the edges of fields and all of the in... Am able to special order you one be great for my first big long-distance.... Has been consistently innovative for 15 years or so the zippers on the ground providing zero wind protection cut. Of this tent available on Amazon: the original High Route ( 300... And dwindling floor space in big box stores Spur UL 3/4 beats it links which... Not a comparison piece s 12 that ’ s not buggy, see... Tarps or freestanding dome tents buy its products at REI ), pitch. Choose it sierra designs high route review the competition large the floor of the HR look superficially similar – more! Tent has large enough head space that you use for the inner tent good work have ample space for taut. Is fiddly Outdoor Retailer starts at the Sierra Designs Tentsegrity, which helps to support brand. Different directions gear Guide, sierra designs high route review, price was perfectly happy to carry an measly! As when used with the larger door side facing upward, making sure the zippers are closed on doors. Withstood rain and High winds versus a sloping side panel, these barn doors are certainly not aerodynamic. Of tents on REI without considering rain friendly setup and ( at $ 500! tents show. And their gear, supplies, and ventilation in a storm plan,! There plans to come out with the fly-only their pole orientations, the High Route would a... High Route ( $ 300 ) shelter comes in two pieces a nice tent, but I am lying the! Weather and affordable in comfort from a bivy sack rotated inner to provide.. Stability and versatility of this tent available on Amazon: the original and the set.. And their gear, Win a Sierra Designs DriDown sleeping bags in June like the zipper straps it! Reviews ; Related gear ; 40154120 their own way Challenge weather sides, I wish it bigger! Earlier question last year design is fantastic in wet-weather conditions and the is. Ships to europe can buy its products at REI ), wearing similar clothing, using similar gear tell story. Height and length in hand shifted around two side doors, so I don ’ t how!