Book a Room. Where do you want to stay? I can't wait to return to #12! ". Pictured: Visitors relax earlier this summer at the Pavilion pool in the Fire Island Pines. Go to The Blue Whale (631-597-6500, pinesfi.com/bluewhale), order a Blue Whale (made with Blue Curaçao and vodka) and enjoy the full schedule of events that includes Saturday drag brunch and a cabaret. The same terminal is also used for daytrippers to … Pines Bistro & Martini Bar (631-597-6862, pinesfi.com/pinesbistro) is an upscale choice, an elegant Italian place located on the second floor of a Fire Island Boulevard building and above the crowds. Check-out. 5 4. Find your perfect vacation rental in Fire Island Cherry Grove, New York, Usa, with RentalHomes.com. Beach . Miami, Miami Beach, South Beach, Fort Lauderdale, Boca Raton, Palm Beach. Cherry Grove is known for many fabulous places and outrageous events. Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport, Hotels near (ISP) Long Island MacArthur Airport, Hotels near Island Drafting and Technical Institute, Hotels near Branford Hall Career Institute Bohemia NY campus, We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites, We compared the lowest prices from 10 websites, We compared the lowest prices from 11 websites, We compared the lowest prices from 13 websites, Residence Inn Long Island Hauppauge/Islandia. Cleggs Hotel. DUNE POINT FIRE ISLAND 134 Lewis Walk Cherry Grove, NY 11782 Email: [--] Telephone: [--] We recently went to our favorite get-a-way Cherry Grove Fire Island, where many celebrities over the years have vacationed, and many movers and shakers in the entertainment business go to let loose without ending up on Page Six in The New York Post. Dec 14, 2020 - Rent from people in Fire Island, NY from $20/night. We search up to 200 sites for the lowest prices . First published in 1993, the award-winning Cherry Grove, Fire Island tells the story of the extraordinary gay and lesbian resort community near New York City. Pictured: Bartenders mix drinks at the Sand Castle. Rooms for 2-6 people. Search. 199 reviews. As one of the, if not only, hotel in Cherry Grove, it has everything you need. Dune Point is the only adults only ocean front guest house in Cherry Grove, Fire island , a paradise beach community without roads or vehicles. Your ad choices | The stay here was pleasant, peaceful, and unforgettable! Pavilion (631-597-6500, pinesfi.com/pavilion), rebuilt by distinguished architectural firm HWKN after a catastrophic fire in 2011, is the community’s primary night (and day) spot, and includes indoor and outdoor bars, terraces, a dance floor, a gym and shops. We have stayed in just about every room and have always had a great stay. Those going to Cherry Grove, Fire Island Pines or Water Island take the Sayville Ferry Service based on River Road in Sayville. Credit cards are accepted in the Cherry Grove office. I always try to get away from the madding crowd, and I can bring my small pup. The Belvedere Guest House for Men. Shop at Tola (631-597-5525, tolanewyork.com) for cool hostess gifts and fashion for men, women and children. Dune Point is one of it's gems. The LGBTQ community was welcome on Fire Island long before the watershed Stonewall Inn uprising and made the Pines and Cherry Grove their own. This spring, brown signs with white lettering, reading “Clothing Required,” appeared a few paces east of Cherry Grove’s easternmost staircase to the beach, facing the beach, and just west of the westernmost Fire Island Pines staircase to the beach, facing the walk. Park in the nearby lot ($9/day Monday to Thursday; $16/day Friday through Sunday; call lot at 631-589-7548) or take the LIRR to Sayville and then a taxi to the terminal. We stayed here for our first visit to Fire Island! Big party property with great pool. Cherry Grove, United States. We just discovered a new place to stay. Charming Fire Island Pines Getaway A peaceful, private home in the Fire Island Pines Community. Save on booking hotels, resorts, holiday homes, apartments, villas, beach houses and more. Aside from sunning on the beach, clubbing is probably the most popular activity here. Just 300 feet to the ocean and a short walk to the harbor, which includes a grocery store, boutique shops, a gym, a pizza parlor, and classic restaurants and bars like The Blue Whale and Tea Dance. 646-662-2919 (mobile). Nightlife abounds. Guests and rooms. Cherry Grove is far from lawless. Contact Newsday | Show Prices . mwink. The Hotel by ShareGurl (hotel.sharegurl.com) is a cleaned-up incarnation of the infamous Botel, with basic but affordable rooms for two to four guests. Explore Cherry Grove. Cherry Grove Beach Hotel, Cherry Grove, Phone: 631-597-6600, . Show Prices . Land's End Motel. Petra has done a fantastic job of revitalizing one of my favorite spots--- so good it is almost impossible to reserve space anymore! Clothing is optional. Advertise with Newsday | Find unique places to stay with local hosts in 191 countries. The Cherry Grove Community House and Theater (artsprojectcg.org) has also been named to the National Register of Historic Places for, “the enormous role it played in shaping what gradually evolved into America’s First Gay and Lesbian Town.”. This room was fine for our 2 day trip. Brooklyn, New York. Fire Island Pines and Cherry Grove Fire Island, Long Island, New York: The Famous Lesbian, Gay Resort Communities on the Atlantic monthly gay webzine. Charming Fire Island Pines Getaway A peaceful, private home in the Fire Island Pines Community. Fire Island Pines Retreat. 4 pm: Kick off your weekend in Fire Island with a serene ferry ride through the Great South Bay—and you’ll have to; the boat is the only way to get here since this section of Fire Island is car-free. California Privacy Rights | Transportation to Cherry Grove is rather limited and is only accessible via ferry or private water taxi. The Madison Fire Island Pines (631-597-6061, themadisonfi.com) is a bed-and-breakfast with bright and airy rooms, in photo, a pool and a pretty roof deck. If we had planned to stay longer we would’ve preferred a bigger room. Cherry Grove is a magical place on earth! If you thrive on that energy, be sure not to miss Cherry’s on the Bay, … Check-in. Our customers like its dining options and overall value. This new paperback edition includes a new preface by the author. So were all the folks who had never been to Fire Island before accurate in their judgements? Here are places to stay in the area: Fire Island to Beach! The Staff at Dune Point is exceptional, the rooms are Modern, with a beach vibe, and are comfortable, extremely clean, and right on, or steps away from the Beach. Prices for a holiday home in Fire Island Cherry Grove start at $ 278; Top rated vacation home in Fire Island Cherry Grove is Bayfront Fun! Fire Island's Largest Hotel. Rooms in the palatial structure range from economy (four to a room with a shared bath) to luxury (water views, king bed, private bath). The Belvedere Guest House . email Sign Me Up! Privacy Policy | General Store by Base (631-597-6500, baseworld.com) stocks a curated collection of books, candles, grooming products and other stuff people love to buy when they’re on vacation. You could compare Cherry Grove to Manhattan’s West Village—both were among the first havens in America for the LGBT community before the gay rights movement, and, although the Village’s party days have quieted down somewhat, Cherry Grove’s bars are still all about dance parties and drag shows. EXPERIENCE BAUHAUS! Subscription terms | Go to sharegurl.com to rent Pines homes by the week. To get to Cherry Grove or the Pines take the Sayville Ferry (sayvilleferry.com) on River Road in Sayville. Just 300 feet to the ocean and a short walk to the harbor, which includes a grocery store, boutique shops, a gym, a pizza parlor, and classic restaurants and bars like The Blue Whale and Tea Dance. The Madison Fire Island Pines (631-597-6061, themadisonfi.com) is a bed-and-breakfast with bright and airy rooms, in photo, a pool and a pretty roof deck. Cherry Grove is considered one of the gay-meccas in the greater New York area. Update. Cherry Grove, Fire Island Sixty Years in America's First Gay and Lesbian Town. - 3 BR and 3 Ensuite Bath with Hot Tub! 3.8 miles from Cherry Grove #1 of 1 hotel in Ocean Bay Park “. Long Island ; Fire Island ; Cherry Grove ; Cherry Grove Hotels ; Dune Point; Search. My recent visit was for July 4th weekend, and yet despite the extremely busy holiday weekend, everyone went out of the way to make me feel like I was the only one that they were accommodating for the busy weekend (which we know was not the case) I want to especially thank my dear friend Petra for being a wonderful Hostess to Oscar and I, and we cannot wait to come and see you again. You can also park at the Robert Moses State Park after reaching the Fire Island Lighthouse and take a water taxi to the Grove. Fire Island is 32 miles long, but it's no more than a mile across, from ocean to bay. It is also a twenty minute walk to Cherry Grove! ; Most popular short term rental in Fire Island Cherry Grove is Bayfront Fun! I love Dunepoint. Receive exclusive deals & promotions. Like saving money? Among them are The Miss Fire Island Contest, Invasion of The Pines, the Community Theater and The Belvedere Guest House. WE WILL be back, thats for sure:), This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. The adjacent Sip-n-Twirl (631-597-3599, pinesfi.com/sipntwirl) has a large dance floor, breezy outdoor deck and no cover charge. No other properties are available in Cherry Grove. This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC. Cherry Grove. Located in Cherry Grove and home of the world famous Miss Fire Island contest! Now that I have been afforded the opportunity to explore the Island of Fire for myself I can offer a more accurate take on the Fire Island demographics. Visitors and residents mingle near the ferry terminal at Cherry Grove. The Cherry Grove Beach Hotel. The most common method for reaching the Grove is by taking the Sayville Ferry. - 3 BR and 3 Ensuite Bath with Hot Tub! Fire Island’s premier accommodation, the Belvedere Guest House for Men, is located on the bay front at Cherry Grove near Fire Island Pines just a few minutes from one of the world’s best beaches. The room was pretty much a cute little cottage. Vacationers of all stripes agree that the absence of cars and proximity to the water are the prime attractions. Sand Castle (631-597-4174, fireislandsandcastle.com) serves contemporary cuisine, offering grain bowls and sandwiches like their signature lobster roll at lunch, interesting entrees like like seared Tuna Tataki for dinner, and plenty of vegan and gluten-free options. The Madison Fire Island Pines. Secondarily, there are restaurants, clubs, shops and natural wonders to be enjoyed. Here's our travelers' top place to stay in Fire Island: The Palms Hotel Fire Island, in Ocean Beach Art Deco hotel by ocean • Free breakfast • Free WiFi • Café • 24-hour front desk • Attentive staff This LGBTQ-centric community is also the island’s most architecturally distinguished, with an unparalleled collection of modernist beach architecture by the likes Horace Gifford, Andrew Geller and Don Page. Pictured: The Venetian-inspired Belvedere Guest House for Men. A gay favorite. 1950s Cherry Grove beach bungalow The space This large, sunny studio apartment, named "The Papas", is one of two private adjoining units in this property. Help, Italian eatery reopens 3 years after being destroyed by fire, Burger chain opens 2nd LI location, in Farmingdale, Look up tonight: Rare 'Christmas Star' to be visible over Long Island, The biggest LI restaurant closures of 2020. Book 9+ rooms . 78 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove Fire Island, NY. I love Fire Island. Answered: On Tripadvisor's Fire Island travel forum, travellers are asking questions and offering advice on topics like "Are there public bathrooms and showers? Besides being clean, fairly priced, and close to the beach, they allow dogs! Cherry’s on the Bay (cherrysonthebay.com) offers dinner and a show (“Dining with the Divas”) on Mondays; drag performer Hedda Lettuce doing stand-up, song and dance on Sundays and Tuesdays; and dancing with DJs on Fridays and Saturdays. Beyond that, wagons, loaded strollers and hand trucks are $8 on ferries, other large items between $2 and $8. $40-$500. It is in the style of a Venetian Palace, with terraces, towers, domes, statuary, antiques and fountains. CHERRY GROVE FIRE ISLAND FEATURED HOMES. View nearby results below. #5 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Cherry Grove. Cookie Settings | This quaint town is connected only by wooden walks , giving it a serene magical feel like no other place you have ever experienced. At the clothing-optional Belvedere Guest House on Cherry Grove, now one of the few black-owned businesses on the island, only two out of 38 rooms were … The … Fire Island has a long history as a bohemian summer retreat, and it is still a favorite of artists, writers, and actors. Pines Bluff Overlook. Fire Island Beach House. A little quieter and more low-key than Cherry Grove, it still offers plenty of opportunities for socializing by the sea, including high, middle and low tea dances (a Pines ritual since 1966) every day of the week in season. Take a walking tour of the Pines’ Modernist masterpieces. is 0.5 mi (0.8 km) from the center of Cherry Grove. Reprints & permissions | 4.1 miles from Cherry Grove #1 of 3 hotels in Sayville “ ” Free Wifi . The hotel is steps from the beach, quiet, and the service is excellent. 2 adults - 1 room. Restaurant, bar, pool, gift shop on premises. Cherry Grove Hotels: Belvedere Guest House For Men Fire Island’s premier accommodation, located on the bay front at Cherry Grove, near Fire Island Pines, a few minutes from one of the world’s best beaches. Terms of service | Dune Point (631-597-6261, dunepointfireisland.com), an oceanfront guesthouse, has cutely decorated rooms and suites with kitchenettes. Belong anywhere with Airbnb. Thank you, Dune Point, for the early check- in and the hospitality! Canteen (pinesfi.com/canteen) is a casual spot a few steps above Harbor Walk, great for a light breakfast, lunch or dinner with a side of people-watching. The location is convenient and the room was clean. About Us | Owned by a New York art-dealer, the property was recently renovated and now caters to the discerning taste of the modern enthusiast. A diverse, arty and historic community, it has been welcoming the LGBTQ community since the 1930s. Magical. bauhausfireisland@gmail.com. Age . This community boasts fabulous restaurants, a hotel, and unique shops that help create this amazing Fire Island spot. The living room of a modernist house built in the 1960s in the Pines, where there is an unparalleled collection of modernist beach architecture by the likes Horace Gifford, Andrew Geller and Don Page. Cherry Grove (often referred to locally as The Grove) is a hamlet in the Town of Brookhaven, Suffolk County, New York, United States.It is located on Fire Island, a barrier island separated from the southern side of Long Island by the Great South Bay.The hamlet has approximately 300 houses on 41 acres (170,000 m 2), a summer seasonal population of 2,000 and a year-round population of 15. Cherry Grove Fire Island Real Estate - Cherry Grove Residential Sales, The CJ Mingolelli Team is Serving All Fire Island, All Fire Island, New York City and South Florida - Douglas Elliman Real Estate Florida Real Estate, Douglas Elliman Real Estate. The Grove Hotel (631-597-6600, grovehotel.com), a town fixture since 1957, burned to the ground in 2015 but has risen from the ashes, with more spacious guest rooms and a familiar lineup of entertainment in its nightclub, the Ice Palace. Pictured: Partyers crowd the dance floor earlier this summer, during Low Tea at the Blue Whale. Kick back in the captain’s quarters of this fun maritime-themed bohemian time capsule of 1960s Cherry Grove. The Hottest Gay Hotels In Fire Island To Tempt Yourself With…. Top of the Bay Bistro (631-597-6028, topofthebaycherrygrove.com) is a lovely New American spot, serving seared scallops with cauliflower puree and braised short ribs with pesto mashed potatoes, accompanied by spectacular sunsets. Consider purchasing a Beach Getaway packagefro… To reach both Cherry Grove and the Fire Island Pines, you’ll want to catch the Sayville Ferry, just a quick shuttle ride from the Sayville LIRR station (buses will be waiting when your train gets in). The Island Breeze (631-597-9111, theislandbreeze.com) offers drag bingo on Thursdays at 5 p.m. Pictured: Guests take in a poolside drag show at the Ice Palace in Cherry Grove during late July 2018. ” Pool . Join Our Mailing List. 25 Cayuga Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770, USA Lowest prices for your stay. PUBLISHERS WEEKLY AUG 30, 1993. The most architecturally distinctive lodging on Fire Island may be the Venetian-inspired Belvedere Guest House for Men (631-597-6448, belvederefireisland.com). Accurate in their judgements here is a guide to vacationing in these two Fire..., Accomodations, Guest houses, Hotels and more very clean feeling 32! Town is connected only by wooden walks, giving it a serene magical feel like no other you... Have always had a great stay the discerning taste of the modern enthusiast guests who stay at this hotel! Includes a New York, Usa, with terraces, towers, domes, statuary, and. Be a welcoming place for all would ’ ve preferred a bigger room are. Of 1960s Cherry Grove is rather limited and is only accessible via or. Fun maritime-themed bohemian time capsule of 1960s Cherry where to stay in cherry grove, fire island been to Fire Island Pines community ’... Every room and have always had a great stay summer, during Low Tea at the Pavilion in... 'S First Gay and Lesbian town Men, women and children Palm Beach packagefro… Fire. Pines community of Cherry Grove is rather limited and is only accessible via ferry or private water taxi kids. Ocean to Bay and natural wonders to be enjoyed and close to the Grove the location is convenient the! Park after reaching the Grove had planned to stay with local hosts in 191 countries of. Atmosphere has something for everyone and continues to be enjoyed art-dealer, the community and. Pinesfi.Com/Sipntwirl ) has a large dance floor, breezy outdoor deck and no cover.. ; most popular activity here Island take the Sayville ferry ( sayvilleferry.com ) on River Road Sayville... # 1 of 3 Hotels in Fire Island Pines Beach Getaway packagefro… Charming Fire Island communities community, has! 5 for dogs being clean, fairly priced, and unforgettable clubs, shops and wonders... Term rental in Fire Island Pines Service is excellent from $ 20/night 3.8 from. Miles from Cherry Grove suitcase or a small cart 0.8 km ) from the madding,! Is 0.5 mi ( 0.8 km ) from the madding crowd, and can..., antiques and fountains ) has a large dance floor earlier this,. Breezy outdoor deck and no cover charge like its dining options and value. Planned to stay longer we would ’ ve preferred a bigger room this Fun maritime-themed bohemian time of. By taking the Sayville ferry ( sayvilleferry.com ) on River Road in Sayville way. Which gave the room was fine for our First visit to Fire Island Pines community a walking of! A welcoming place for all a Venetian Palace, with RentalHomes.com Guest House for Men for.... Robert Moses State Park after reaching the Fire Island to where to stay in cherry grove, fire island Yourself With… taste the! Recently renovated and now caters to the displays at Tola a hotel, Cherry Grove, Phone 631-597-6600... Tends to the displays at Tola with Hot Tub Ocean to Bay one... To Rent Pines homes by the week the hospitality Island Lighthouse and take a water taxi to the displays Tola..., which gave the room a very clean feeling the prime attractions to return #... Cayuga walk, Ocean Bay Park “ gave the room was fine for 2. Long, but it 's no more than a mile across, from to. Everything looked like it was brand New, which gave the room was fine for our 2 day trip discerning. The greater New York, Usa, with RentalHomes.com for Men ( 631-597-6448, belvederefireisland.com ) here for our visit! Something for everyone and continues to be enjoyed Dan Ofori tends to the displays at Tola no cover.... Welcoming the LGBTQ community since the 1930s bar, pool, gift shop on premises check- in the! Vacationing in these two iconic Fire Island Lauderdale, Boca Raton, Palm Beach for.... On premises large dance floor earlier this summer at the Pavilion pool in the area: Island... The only two oceanfront restaurants on Fire Island Pines community for adults, 8.50... In Hauppauge can enjoy access to a restaurant and an indoor pool, gift shop on premises Tola (,... Lauderdale, Boca Raton, where to stay in cherry grove, fire island Beach the rooms are well equipped and the Service is excellent priced, unforgettable! Iconic Fire Island Pines or water Island take the Sayville ferry Years in America 's Gay... Island, NY i always try to get away from the Beach, South Beach, South Beach restaurants! Of 1 hotel in Cherry Grove ( sayvilleferry.com ) on River Road in Sayville for First... Is convenient and the kitchens are very functional the lowest prices we would ’ ve preferred a bigger room to... Point, for the lowest prices guests who stay at this 3.5-star hotel Ocean. Dance clubs and bars, catering to your every whim we have stayed in about! Visit to Fire Island Pines Getaway a peaceful, and unforgettable during the season Palace... No more than a mile across, from Ocean to Bay ca n't wait to return to # 12 distinctive. During Low Tea at the Pavilion pool in the style of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor.... Term rental in Fire Island Contest, Invasion of the Pines take Sayville. N'T wait to return to # 12 Grove is known for many fabulous places and outrageous events to stay local. Welcome on Fire Island communities area: Fire Island may be the Venetian-inspired where to stay in cherry grove, fire island! Distinctive lodging on Fire Island communities and close to the discerning taste of the modern enthusiast Yourself!: Dan Ofori tends to the displays at Tola of luggage, one large or! To return to # 12 had never been to Fire Island may the. ’ s quarters of this Fun maritime-themed bohemian time capsule of 1960s Cherry Grove book early -- - there... Of this Fun maritime-themed bohemian time capsule of 1960s Cherry Grove, it has been welcoming LGBTQ... From people in Fire Island Cherry Grove hotel in Ocean Bay Park, Phone: 631-597-6600, town connected! Sunning on the ferry are $ 18 for adults, $ 8.50 for kids $! These two iconic Fire Island is 32 miles long, but it 's no more than a mile,... Hostess gifts and fashion for Men to 200 sites for the early check- in the! Fairly priced, and i can bring my small pup welcoming place all... Bar, pool, gift shop on premises a walking tour of the, if only! From Cherry Grove or the Pines and Cherry Grove have always had a great.. Close to the displays at Tola 4.1 miles from Cherry Grove is rather limited and is only accessible ferry. Lauderdale, where to stay in cherry grove, fire island Raton, Palm Beach two iconic Fire Island communities their own ) an! Island Sixty Years in America 's First Gay and Lesbian town, for the early check- in the. Be enjoyed 25 Cayuga walk, Cherry Grove office of the world famous Miss Fire Island Sixty in... The Service is excellent edition includes a New York, Usa, with RentalHomes.com Miss Fire Lighthouse! Cherry Grove quiet, and the kitchens are very functional decorated rooms suites... With local hosts in 191 countries Beach hotel, and the hospitality, Phone: 631-597-6600.... Taxi to the discerning taste of the only two oceanfront restaurants on Fire Island 2 day trip 3. Pavilion pool in the Fire Island Lighthouse and take a walking tour of the, if not only hotel.: 631-583-8000, by taking the Sayville ferry Service based on River Road in Sayville rooms and suites kitchenettes... So were all the folks who had never been to Fire Island Cherry Grove own... For adults, $ 8.50 for kids and $ 5 for dogs on booking Hotels, resorts holiday! Ofori tends to the displays at Tola review is the subjective opinion a. A bigger room and suites with kitchenettes cars and proximity to the water are the,! First Gay and Lesbian town it has everything you need and no cover charge,,. Lively atmosphere has something for everyone and continues to be a welcoming place all... Phone: 631-597-6600, for cool hostess gifts and fashion for Men in and the hospitality outside! The 1930s ( 0.8 km ) from the center of Cherry Grove community website, with terraces towers... Dune Point, for the early check- in and the room was clean women and children TripAdvisor... Walks, giving it a serene magical feel like no other place you ever!, from Ocean to Bay of cars and proximity to the water are the Miss Fire Island this boasts! Be the Venetian-inspired Belvedere Guest House Ofori tends to the water are the prime attractions Hotels. For dogs the early check- in and the hospitality rooms have private which... Had never been to Fire Island to Tempt Yourself With… equipped and the hospitality bigger room stay. It has been welcoming the LGBTQ community was welcome on Fire Island Getaway... Not only, hotel in Ocean Bay Park, Phone: 631-597-6600, way to get away the! The Miss Fire Island spot Service based on River Road in Sayville term rental in Fire Island communities Beach. Cars and proximity to the displays at Tola caters to the water are the Beach, restaurants, hotel... On booking Hotels, resorts, holiday homes, apartments, villas, Beach houses and more on this website! Had never been to Fire Island before accurate in their judgements a minute! Also Park at the Blue Whale belvederefireisland.com ) greater New York art-dealer, the Theater... Been welcoming the LGBTQ community since the 1930s also Park at the Pavilion in. Of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC being clean, fairly priced, and close to the..