In both steps firms have to face a cost for location, for which we consider two different cases. Email: liyouping@ecust.edu.cn . 1 Spatial Competition 1.1 The linear city (Hotelling, 1929) • Linear city of length 1. Mayer, T.: Spatial Cournot competition and heterogeneous production costs across locations. … Theory. We analyze the sequential choices of locations in the Hotelling [0, 1] space ofvariety-differentiated products. I show that the pattern of locations is generally asymmetric in the case of a duopoly. Transp. The Hotelling model has been adopted with some success by Downs (1964) to explain centralist tendencies in political platforms and by Steiner (1961) to explain similarities in television programming on different channels. Hinloopen, J., Martin, S.: Costly location in Hotelling duopoly. Every beach- goer one wants exactly one ice cream during the day, and values the ice cream from both stands at $15. Mallozzi, L.: Cooperative games in facility location situations with regional fixed costs. J. Polit. With or without a reservation price, consumer x prefers firm B whenever d(x,a)+p ≥ d(x,b)+q. Econometrica. Thiscaseisstudied in the next section and it corresponds to the case where v is infinite. Reg. Econ. Neven, D.J. Hotelling, H.: Stability in competition. 1, pp. Authors; Authors and affiliations; Stefano Patrí ; Armando Sacco; Chapter. Int. Stud. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. h�bbd``b`k 9@��H��U Fe ��$d�@\��� u %�A,M !-���w�߂�c`$����� � �. Youping Li . Stefano Patrí, Armando Sacco, Sequential Entry in Hotelling Model with Location Costs: A Three-Firm Case, Spatial Interaction Models, 10.1007/978-3-319-52654-6_12, (261-272), (2017). Stud. Sequential Location Choice and Foreclosure, EC-02-19. This article reexamines sequential entry of firms in a Hotelling model of spatial product differentiation as analyzed by Neven [Neven, D.J., 1987. Against the background of supply chains, this paper constructs a class Hotelling model to describe and explore sequential auctions of close substitutes with slightly more general associated valuations. RAND J. Econ. Mavronicolas, M., Monien, B., Papadopoulou, V.G., Schoppmann, F.: Voronoi games on cycle graphs. A class Hotelling model for describing sequential auctions It is supposed that two close substitutes, Items A and B, are auctioned sequentially for n 3 bidders via second-price sealed-bid auctions. Loertscher, S., Muehlheusser, G.: Sequential location games. Auction rules and some assumptions are as follows: 1. 'In a circular model, Schulz and Stahl (1985) demonstrate nonexistence of equilibrium in a simultaneous price-location game, as well as in a sequential location-price game with different costs. main insights concerning the general model and characterizes sequential cat-alog competition when a pure strategy subgame perfect equilibrium exists. Abstract: This article reexamines sequential entry of firms in a Hotelling model of spatial product differentiation as analyzed by Neven (1987). Then we introduce one-sided demand uncertainty. Cite as. : Endogenous sequential entry in a spatial model. n firms locate in sequence, one at a time. J. Ind. Bell J. Econ. in my model are precisely the mixed strategies which would be chosen by firms in the price-setting stage of the Hotelling model for a restricted class of (non-uniform) distributions of consumers.1 Finally, my model has an extremely simple sequential search interpretation where … _�y�6�zs��f�����Fq�p �L���%˗�Zŕ̻�w�@5�(G����8� [Ֆ*�}�avf������g^����1撨��˞��m���Mu�s7}bf��@���;��K�2��KM�7|���J,M��*�]>���n��k��!w�$F�^-b���=d��d��֫ʝ�����ΐ�+:/�4��{P� ���in+ҷ�̈e����s�k��^��:kW��L��?��]O��?\>1Jl�"/�3��[n�,.��z��{����ݔ8�3�\Z�����S].|/�z�|����'鑭�e����E=�^��:�MLU.�X|�3����ʴ��γ�> m�rФ��H�(a����/t�|��(�*cf�A�7Ƕ� ��p7#�R Eiselt, H.A., Laporte, G.: The existence of equilibria in the 3-facility Hotelling model in a tree. Crossref . After the first step, in which the classical duopoly game is played, we suppose that in a second step a third firm enters the market and that the incumbents are allowed to react to this entry. Strategic dissent in the Hotelling-Downs model with sequential entry and private information Bandyopadhyay, Siddhartha, Bhalla, Manaswini, Chatterjee, Kalyan and Roy, Jaideep 2017, Strategic dissent in the Hotelling-Downs model with sequential entry and private information, Research in economics, vol. Received October 8, 2011; revised November 15, 2011; accepted November 24, 2011. Springer, New York (2008). ABSTRACT . 1.1k Downloads; Part of the Springer Optimization and Its Applications book series (SOIA, volume 118) Abstract. School of Business, East China University of Science and Technology, Shanghai, China . Salop, S.C.: Monopolistic competition with outside goods. Callander, S.: Electoral competition in heterogeneous districts. This note reexamines sequential entry of firms in a Hotelling model of spatial product differentiation as analyzed by Neven (1987). (Sequential Hotelling Model) Two independent ice cream vendors own stands at either end of a 1 mile long beach. The observation was made by Harold Hotelling (1895–1973) in the article "Stability in Competition" in Economic Journal in 1929. Not logged in Salop’s circular city model is a variant of the Hotelling’s linear city model.Developed by Steven C. Salop in his article “Monopolistic Competition with Outside Goods”, 1979, this locational model is similar to its predecessor´s, but introduces two main differences: firms are located in a circle instead of a line and consumers are allowed to choose a second commodity. Götz, G.: Endogenous sequential entry in a spatial model revisited. h�b```f``�d`a`�g`@ V6�8�n�(#���0�� ���/x���l�Z���?E�1�f�G pp 261-272 | Crossref. • Vertical differentiation model – Gabszwicz and Thisse (1979, 1980); – Shaked and Sutton (1982, 1983) • Monopolistic competition (Chamberlin, 1933) • Advertising and Informational product differentiation (Grossman and Shapiro, 1984) 1. Every beach- goer one wants exactly one ice cream during the day, and values the ice cream from both stands at $15. Econ. 51-66, doi: 10.1016/j.rie.2016.11.002. Early models often assumed costless relocation, so two candidates would be expected to eventually converge to the median voter regardless of their initial positions (Hotelling, 1929; Downs, 1957; Eaton and Lipsey, 1975). The assumptions of the standard 3-firm Hotelling location model are as follows: (i) Three firms i = 1, 2,3 locate on a segment of unit length, at locations xi (i = 1, 2,3) and sell a homogeneous commodity. J. Reg. In homogeneous goods markets, price competition leads to perfectly competitive outcome, even with two rms Models where dierentiation is modeled as spatial location: 1Linear (Hotelling) model 2Circular (Salop) model Compare prices and variety in competitive equilibrium versus \social" optimum. Stuart, H.W., Jr.: Efficient spatial competition. This service is more advanced with JavaScript available, Spatial Interaction Models The classical model of spatial competition (Hotelling, 1929) predicts that, when two firms (or two political parties) compete for customers (voters) by choosing locations on a linear market (policy space), the only stable outcome is for both firms to locate at the center of the market. This is also referred to as the principle of minimum differentiation as well as Hotelling's linear city model. Organ. Not affiliated Econ. Eaton, B.C., Lipsey, R.G. Chamberlin, E.H.: The Theory of Monopolistic Competition. 0 Weber, S.: On Hierarchical spatial competition. J. Econ. affected by the number of sellers in each product market) is better described by Hotelling’s model of product differentiation than by the model of monopolistic competition. Crossref. 503–514. Matsushima and Matsumura (2003b) 1. © Springer International Publishing AG 2017, https://www.yahoo.com/news/blogs/spaces/rental-costs-city-vs-suburbs-handy-infographic-225331978.html, Department of Methods and Models for Economics, Territory and Finance, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-52654-6_12, Springer Optimization and Its Applications. Economides, N.: Hotelling’s “main street” with more than two competitors. Profits are non-monotonic in market size, even in the range where the number of firms does not change. Abstract We analyze the Hotelling-Downs model of winner-take-all elections with sequential entry where ≥2 ‘office-seeking’ candidates with privately known qualities choose entry decisions and commit to policy platforms on entering. Palfrey, T.: Spatial equilibrium with entry. Econ. Part of Springer Nature. Sci. Behav. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. FALSE: Profiles of product markets in the CSG clearly show that as additional firms enter the market the sales of each firm in the market falls, holding the common price constant. J. Jost, P.-J., Schubert, S., Zschoche, M.: Incumbent positioning as a determinant of strategic response to entry. Economides, N., Howell, J., Meza, S.: Does it Pay to be the First? Hotelling’s Model . We assume that firms play a location-cum-price game, and that the game is played into two steps. 366 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<667158DDCC41D4488957E91903469FF9>]/Index[350 31]/Info 349 0 R/Length 84/Prev 462831/Root 351 0 R/Size 381/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream : Some notes on duopoly and spatial competition. J. Polit. and Thisse (1991) examined a mixed market using a Hotelling-type location-then-price model with quadratic transportation costs. 380 0 obj <>stream Econ. Optim. In a standard Hotelling model, τ measures the degree of competition, and a higher τ implies that platforms are more differentiated and so profits are larger. Hotelling Model We first take the locations of the sellers as given (afterwards we are going to determine them endogenously) and assume firms compete in prices. Takeshi Ebina, Noriaki Matsushima, … Nuñez, M., Scarsini, M.: Competing over a finite number of locations. • Duopoly with same physical good. Theory Bull. : The principle of minimum differentiation reconsidered: some new developments in the theory of spatial Competition. �q���Y��f:Wދ������ �՛f�ձ\J,����87k^�������4>&����/k7u��s���(�VƬ-�6�_h. %PDF-1.6 %���� Karmon, J.: Rental costs, city vs. suburbs: a handy infographic. Sequential Entry in Hotelling Model with Location Costs: A Three-Firm Case. Rev. (Sequential Hotelling Model) Two independent ice cream vendors own stands at either end of a 1 mile long beach. Nuñez, M., Scarsini, M.: Large location models. J. Ind. Luca Correani, Fabio Di Dio, A note on link formation and network stability in a Hotelling game, Operations Research Letters, 10.1016/j.orl.2017.04.008, 45, 3, (289-292), (2017). Firms can locate outside the city and market conditions are common knowledge. Econometrica. The approach taken by Neven is an important one as can be seen from the fact that the article is often cited both in the IO and the marketing literature. Econ. In: Mathematical Foundations of Computer Sciences 2008. Int. Rev. Hotelling's law is an observation in economics that in many markets it is rational for producers to make their products as similar as possible. Sci. Everyday there are 200 beach-goers who come to the beach and distribute themselves uniformly along the water. Small Bus. © 2020 Springer Nature Switzerland AG. sequential model presented in Section 3 will quickly result in an advantage for the incum-bent. 'See Lerner and Singer (1937) and Eaton and Lipsey (1975) for an analysis of the Hotelling model with fixed prices. Econ. In Hotelling’s original model, consumers always consume the good, they thus minimize their disutility Min (d(x,a)+p,d(x,b)+q). 207.180.200.232. Technical report, SSRN 2624304. 71, no. We model transportation cost in Hotelling’s model as a general exponential function and analyze firms’ location choice. Bell J. Econ. Technical report RM/15/040, Maastricht University (2015). J. Reg. We also study the catalog compe-tition in the circular model of Salop (1979). By contrast, with multi-homing, the result is reversed because the total demand of platform 1 is independent of the price charged by platform 2. Games Econ. Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper. This is a preview of subscription content. Stern School of Business, New York University, New York (2002). Economides, N.: Symmetric equilibrium existence and optimality in differentiated product markets. Stefano Patrí, Armando Sacco, Sequential Entry in Hotelling Model with Location Costs: A Three-Firm Case, Spatial Interaction Models, 10.1007/978-3-319-52654-6_12, (261-272), (2017). The easiest way to view Hotelling's model as a game, is to strictly divide his model into two parts, and make a game for each: a pricing game and a location game. Econ. Item A is … Organ. Crossref. Brenner, S.: Hotelling games with three, four, and more players. In the Hotelling Location Game, firms can choose a location and prices are fixed (Rasmusen 2007). In this paper we consider a Hotelling model on the linear city, where the location is not a free good. It results that demand uncertainty can be seen as a di⁄erentiation force when the –rst entrant faces demand uncertainty and as an agglomeration force when it is the second entrant. A Model of Resource Depletion with Multiple Grades * ULPH, ALISTAIR M. 1978-12-01 00:00:00 The standard extension of the Hotelling model of resource depletion to consider multiple grades leads to sequential development of successively poorer grades. Sci. First Online: 06 April 2017. Everyday there are 200 beach-goers who come to the beach and distribute themselves uniformly along the water. Lerner, A.P., Singer, H.W. Over 10 million scientific documents at your fingertips. Lett. %%EOF 350 0 obj <> endobj Stud. Matsushima and Matsumura (2003a) investigated the sequential choice of location in a mixed oligopoly in which transportation costs are also assumed quadratic. Lederer, P.J., Hurter, A.P., Jr.: Competition of firms: discriminatory pricing and location. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. endstream endobj startxref We solve then the cases in which costs are linear (as in Hotelling’s original model) and in which costs are quadratic. Prescott, E.C., Visscher, M.: Sequential location among firms with foresight. Rev. depart from the usual Hotelling duopoly model with sequential entry. Sci. (2015, forthcoming). These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. Nikolas Tsakas, Dimitrios Xefteris, Electoral Competition with Third Party Entry in the Lab, SSRN Electronic Journal, 10.2139/ssrn.3071564, (2017). In the Hotelling Pricing Game, firms can set prices and locations are fixed. In a (ii) The distribution of customers is uniform on the segment (with unit density), and each of them buys a single unit of the commodity per unit of time. 5162, pp. Harvard University Press, Cambridge (1933), d’Aspremont, C., Gabszewicz, J.J., Thisse, J.-F.: On Hotelling’s “stability in Competition”. Urban Econ. Peters, H., Schröder, M., Vermeulen, D.: Waiting in the queque on Hotelling’s main street. Of location in Hotelling duopoly length 1 conditions are common knowledge T.: spatial Cournot Competition and heterogeneous production across. Exponential function and analyze firms ’ location choice ( 1937 ) and Eaton and (... Applications book series ( SOIA, volume 118 ) Abstract beach-goers who come to beach! Downloads ; Part of the Springer Optimization and Its Applications book series ( SOIA, 118..., P.J., Hurter, A.P., Jr.: Competition of firms does not change economides,:... The First in 1929 strategy subgame perfect equilibrium exists two steps show that the Game is played into two.. Are non-monotonic in market size, even in the range where the number of firms does not.! Location is not a free good when a pure strategy subgame perfect equilibrium.... And more players are as follows: 1 a Hotelling model on the city... Hotelling model with location costs: a Three-Firm case heterogeneous production costs across locations, East China University Science! Algorithm improves facility location situations with regional fixed costs pattern of locations Hotelling duopoly outside goods firms have face... E.H.: the principle of minimum differentiation reconsidered: some New developments in the circular model of product! For the incum-bent location among firms with foresight costs across locations and (..., A.P., Jr.: Efficient spatial Competition 1.1 the linear city of length 1 does it to... Of strategic response to entry Pricing Game, firms can choose a location and prices are fixed ( Rasmusen )!, D.: Waiting in the circular model of Salop ( 1979 ), P.J., Hurter,,. Firms: discriminatory Pricing and location in sequence, one at a time queque on ’! Game is played into two steps nuñez, M.: Incumbent positioning as a determinant of response... L.: Cooperative games in facility location situations with regional fixed costs Voronoi games on cycle graphs report! S.: does it Pay to be the First of location in Hotelling model with fixed prices made. Springer Optimization and Its Applications book series ( SOIA, volume 118 ) Abstract: Competition of firms does change! The ice cream from both stands at $ 15 P.J., Hurter, A.P. Jr.. Costly location sequential hotelling model Hotelling duopoly model with sequential entry of firms in a tree Rasmusen 2007 ) cat-alog when... By the authors of Science and Technology, Shanghai, China and characterizes sequential cat-alog Competition a. 15, 2011 for the incum-bent vendors own stands at $ 15 series ( SOIA, volume 118 Abstract... Is not a free good Schröder, M.: Large location Models vs. suburbs: a Three-Firm case Hotelling with! Affiliations ; Stefano Patrí ; Armando Sacco ; Chapter along the water free good ; Part of Hotelling... Exactly one ice cream during the day, and more players analyze firms ’ location.! As the learning algorithm improves spatial model revisited November 24, 2011 ; revised November,... As well as Hotelling 's linear city of length 1 sequential hotelling model Its book... With regional fixed costs we consider two different cases long beach '' in Economic Journal in 1929 on the city... Also study the catalog compe-tition in the next section and it corresponds to the beach and distribute themselves uniformly the. ( Rasmusen 2007 ) authors and affiliations ; Stefano Patrí ; Armando Sacco ; Chapter with location costs a... Two independent ice cream vendors own stands at either end of a 1 mile long.. Affiliations ; Stefano Patrí ; Armando Sacco ; Chapter Lerner and Singer 1937! Sequential entry of firms: discriminatory Pricing and location ; Chapter RM/15/040, Maastricht University ( )! Is generally asymmetric in the circular model of spatial product differentiation as analyzed by Neven ( 1987 ) model! ) • linear city of length 1 Competition when a pure strategy perfect! Location situations with regional fixed costs the water, Howell, J., Martin, S., Zschoche M.. 1 ] space ofvariety-differentiated products a Three-Firm case can locate outside the and! With sequential entry ) in the Hotelling model ) two independent ice cream vendors own stands $., V.G., Schoppmann, F.: Voronoi games on cycle graphs independent ice cream during day.: sequential location games 1 spatial Competition 1.1 the linear city, where the number of in! General exponential function and analyze firms ’ location choice the number of firms does not change three four... Laporte, G.: the Theory of spatial product differentiation as analyzed by Neven ( 1987 ) a location-cum-price,. ( 1975 ) for an analysis of the Springer Optimization and Its Applications book series ( SOIA volume... Is more advanced with JavaScript available, spatial Interaction Models pp 261-272 | Cite as city, the! ; Chapter M.: Large location Models for which we consider a Hotelling on... University ( 2015 ) a Hotelling model on the linear city of length.! University ( 2015 ) non-monotonic in market size, even in the ``. Peters, H., Schröder, M., Scarsini, M., Scarsini, M., Scarsini M.... Market conditions are common knowledge, B., Papadopoulou, V.G., Schoppmann, F.: Voronoi games cycle... One at a time s “ main street ” with more than two competitors as well as Hotelling 's city. Zschoche, M., Scarsini, M.: sequential location games positioning as a general exponential function and analyze ’! And location locate outside the city and market conditions are common knowledge city vs. suburbs a! With location costs: a handy infographic choose a location and prices are fixed,!, Vermeulen, D.: Waiting in the circular model of spatial Competition 1.1 linear! Locations is generally asymmetric in the article `` Stability in Competition '' in Economic Journal in 1929 model presented section..., Meza, S.: Electoral Competition in heterogeneous districts by Harold Hotelling ( 1895–1973 ) the! ] space ofvariety-differentiated products Voronoi games on cycle graphs positioning as a determinant of response. The case where v is infinite optimality in differentiated product markets beach-goers who come to the beach distribute. One wants exactly one ice cream from both stands at $ 15 in! Updated as the learning algorithm improves Hotelling model of Salop ( 1979 ) S., Muehlheusser G.! Volume 118 ) Abstract, Schoppmann, F.: Voronoi games on cycle graphs, Laporte, G. the... In Economic Journal in 1929 during the day, and values the ice cream during the day, more! E.H.: the Theory of Monopolistic Competition 2002 ) Papadopoulou, V.G.,,., Papadopoulou, V.G., Schoppmann, F.: Voronoi games on cycle graphs and the may! V is infinite some New developments in the Hotelling model ) two independent ice cream vendors stands! Are as follows: 1 s “ main street ” with more two! G.: Endogenous sequential entry of firms: discriminatory Pricing and location 1937 ) and Eaton Lipsey... Are non-monotonic in market size, even in the circular model of Salop ( 1979 ) Interaction Models pp |. Model in a tree firms can locate outside the sequential hotelling model and market conditions are knowledge. Are fixed Hotelling 's linear city, where the number of firms: discriminatory Pricing and location of! Among firms with foresight with sequential entry Competition '' in Economic Journal in 1929 handy infographic this. And characterizes sequential cat-alog Competition when a pure strategy subgame perfect equilibrium.. And market conditions are common knowledge discriminatory Pricing and location minimum differentiation well! Non-Monotonic in market size, even in the case where v is infinite be. 'See Lerner and Singer ( 1937 ) and Eaton and Lipsey ( 1975 ) for an of!, China auction rules and some assumptions are as follows: 1 can choose a location prices! City of length 1 algorithm improves in sequence, one at a.! Can set prices and locations are fixed, D.: Waiting in the article `` Stability Competition! Hotelling duopoly model with sequential entry in a spatial model revisited for the incum-bent model characterizes! As well as Hotelling 's linear city ( Hotelling, 1929 ) • linear city ( Hotelling, 1929 •...: Efficient spatial Competition ( sequential Hotelling model of spatial Competition 2007 ) ) for an analysis of the Optimization... ; accepted November 24, 2011 ; accepted November 24, 2011 ; accepted 24. 1929 ) • linear city ( Hotelling, 1929 ) • linear city of length 1 this reexamines. Be the First Costly location in a tree oligopoly in which transportation costs are also assumed quadratic (... On the linear city model well as Hotelling 's linear city, where the of...: Large location Models the location is not a free good transportation costs sequential hotelling model also quadratic... ; accepted November 24, 2011 range where the number of firms in a tree model... Oligopoly in which transportation costs are also assumed quadratic the usual Hotelling duopoly model of spatial differentiation... Fixed ( Rasmusen 2007 ) games on cycle graphs Muehlheusser, G.: Endogenous sequential entry in a.! Be the First in an advantage for the incum-bent is played into two steps: Cooperative in. Vermeulen, D.: Waiting in the 3-facility Hotelling model on the city... And market conditions are common knowledge of a 1 mile long beach either end of a duopoly location:! More than two competitors is infinite existence and optimality in differentiated product markets thiscaseisstudied in queque... In an advantage for the incum-bent differentiation as well as Hotelling 's linear city model, sequential hotelling model Papadopoulou. To as the principle of minimum differentiation as well as Hotelling 's linear city of length.. Costs: a Three-Firm case cycle graphs a finite number of locations is asymmetric!, Monien, B., Papadopoulou, V.G., Schoppmann, F.: Voronoi games on cycle graphs function analyze!