Of course it's a no brainer that 8 shots > 7 shots. We finish our best .44 magnum revolver reviews with a very special Smith & Wesson model – The 629. Weight: 33.7–45 oz. Dimensionally, the revolver appears to be the same size as the 6-shot GP100. In someway the 7-shot cylinder may actually be stronger. 6 Six-Shot .357 Magnum Revolvers For Competition Shooting. Okay, looking at both of these and trying to decide which is a better gun. By Bob Campbell Published on April 8, 2014 in Firearms. The 5-round revolver allows for a larger round more safely. Does the 686 have a baby brother that's best for carry. I'm kinda leaning to the 66 because of the 7 shot cylinder but which is really the better gun? I'd get a 6 shot, something just doesn't feel right about getting a 7 shot. Before we get to the list, we’ll talk about what an eight-shot revolver is good for and how the four products we chose to review ended up on our list. At a Glance: Our Top Picks for 8 Shot Revolvers. Seller: Jays Guns and Accessories Jays Guns and Accessories. I hate the balance of the 6" L frames; I also found the 4" easier to shoot quickly as all that mass of the 6" out front took longer to settle down. Overall Length: 8–12.5 in. Do any of you guys carry the 686 concealed? H&R Sportsman (.22 LR nine-shot revolver 6-inch barrel – blued finish); Manual Ejecting Model.32 S&W or .38 S&W cal, 6-shot (.32 cal.) An accurate ‘meaty’ revolver… The S&W 629 comes with classic, timeless style and will certainly be noticed wherever you tote it. She perfers the revolver over the semi-auto. Free & Fast Shipping on all orders of $90.00 or more! The "N rounds should be enough" argument is used typically (although not always) by people who are unfamiliar with situations that require a firearm. The 6 shot is better if you're planning to do IDPA with it since they don't allow you to load more than 6. The advantage to me of the 6-shot is price...There a great bargains out there in 6-shot 686's. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. The one other drawback for the 7 shooter are there are fewer brands of speedloaders available for them. The Taurus 608 and the Smith & Wesson 327 are the only two models I am aware of that to my knowledge produce a 8 shot revolver in .357 Magnum. With its' bright fiber optic sight and smooth double action trigger it was fun and easy to shoot. The revolver weighs a hefty 40 ounces empty and my Lyman electronic trigger pull tester gizmo says the single action trigger breaks at 4.5 pounds while the double action pull is about 12 pounds. Thanks to a helpful member who X-posted over on r/gundeals that Ruger was coming out with a new 7 shot GP100. As for 6 or 7 shot - personal preference. Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by xena, Jan 25, 2005. The double-action GP100 is a fine example—previously only available in .357 Mag. Full Details More from this Seller. … All information is provided "as is" with all faults without warranty of any kind, either express or implied. Charter Arms is calling it the Professional, unveiling it at this year’s Concealed Carry Expo. Source(s): ruger gp100 taurus 66 7 shot 357 revolvers: https://shortly.im/kKVRG. These included the 850 fps 148-grain wadcutter, a 110-grain JHP at over 1,000 fps and the 125-grain JHP at 959 fps. 0 0. One other possible benefit of the seven-shot cylinder is lighter rotational inertia. 1 of 6 Ruger GP100 Match Champion Based on the GP100 that evolved from the Security Six revolver in 1985, the Match Champion was designed with the competitor in mind. with six-shot cylinders—Ruger is now offering a seven-shot version of the reliable revolver. It felt the exact same to me. barrel, modified American Double Action mechanism and frame. 2 0. pfarr. Good evening -I want to begin shooting ICORE and Steel Challenge matches and want to get one gun, for the time being, that will let me be competitive in both. I used three choices from Double Tap ammunition in the first evaluation. HKS makes a 7 shot model, but Safariland does not. 7 shot Ruger GP100: technical features The new model is available in 2.50" (63 mm), 4.20" (106 mm) and 6" (152 mm) barrel lengths. All information is provided "as is" with all faults without warranty of any kind, either express or implied. In all likelihood, she will be shooting a 38 Spl +P load. 2 Image(s) Smith & Wesson 686-6, .357 Magnum. Testing of the sample GP100 began with shooting five consecutive, five-shot groups from a sandbag rest at 25 yds. I lifted the piece, checked the cylinder and hefted the balance. Constructed of stainless steel, … Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by CTGunner, Apr 10, 2010. This was Ruger’s new GP100 seven-shot, mid-frame .357 Mag. When preparing my answer, I noted a response from Tom Alspaugh (below) that is accurate and best describes the differences. Any insight is appreciated. Although most of the 686 Revolvers listed were of the 7 Shot variety I chose a 6 Shooter. Thank you for your input and responses in advance. Height: 5.5 in. Ruger’s 7 shot, steel GP100 builds on the legacy of earlier Ruger models like the Security 6. Cynthia. 7 Smith & Wesson – 629 Handgun 44 Magnum 44 Special 6.5in. The stainless revolver lay gleaming among the rubble of a day’s hardcore use, late afternoon sunlight reflecting from the pale sides of dozens of spent cartridges. Home Of The First Capitol Of The Confederate State. At some important turning point in the movie, there was some kind of gunfight, and the star had a revolver, which would classically be a six-shooter, but then as a surprise, he had one more bullet and shot the bad guy. .frankly, I wouldn't be able to afford new...besides, I don't care for the lock mechanism the new ones have. To help you find the right eight-shot revolver for you, we put together a list of four of the best revolvers with that specific capacity currently on the market as of this writing. The weakest point in a cylinder, with an even number of chambers, is stop notch in the cylinder since this … Somewhere between the Eastern Block states and Flo. That's my two cents anyhow. If you need you use "Ruger only" loads you should have gone with a more capably cartridge. So I'd definitely get a 686 regardless but look for something else for IDPA. Ruger totally messed up on that model and people can't even load all 7 rounds for many types of ammunition. Neither The High Road nor any of its directors, members, managers, employees, agents, vendors, or suppliers will be liable for any direct, indirect, general, bodily injury, compensatory, special, punitive, consequential, or incidental damages including, without limitation, lost profits or revenues, costs of replacement goods, loss or damage to data arising out of the use or inability to use this forum or any services associated with this forum, or damages from the use of or reliance on the information present on this forum, even if you have been advised of the possibility of such damages. The distance between adjacent chambers appears to be larger on the seven-shot cylinder than the distance between the charge holes and bolt cuts on the six-shot cylinder. Although The High Road has attempted to provide accurate information on the forum, The High Road assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of the information. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. using three, diverse .357 Mag. Both Stainless, 6'' barrel. revolver. From Ruger's new GP100 MC to Chiappa's Rhino 40DS, these six-shot .357 magnum revolvers are born and bred to win! Charter Arms is breaking the mold with their latest new gun, a 7-shot small-frame revolver chambered for the unlikely .32 H&R Magnum. Aside from Tradition, I felt that the 6 shot Cylinder would be Stronger because there would more Steel Between Charge Holes. The revolver was actually docile. He then said something about having this specially made 7-shooter, and this came as some big surprise. GA Sales: 8253. Speed from leather was fast as I drew from a Wright Leatherworks belt scabbard. Gun #: 905946284. I've owned a few examples of each over the years. (I'm looking the specs up to get specifics). I’m a revolver man at heart. I approved. The classic GP100 has enjoyed a reputation of being a stout workhorse that can handle a steady diet of full power .357 Magnum rounds, while also being capable of firing the soft shooting, and less expensive .38 Special ammunition. It ran like a champ and recoil was amazingly mild. $1,129.99. 2afreedom, Mar 13, 2016 #1. I just Bought Used a 6 Shot 686-6 on GB. Ruger GP100 VS Taurus 66 7 Shot .357 Revolvers? The 7 shot is even stronger than the 6 because the locking lugs are offset. Price wise the Taurus seems to be the better priced of the two but they have a reputation for less than great customer service should you have to send your gun in for factor service. I am setup to load 9mm and .45acp on my Dillon 550 and dont want to purchase the dies, components to load another caliber at this time. 4 years ago. If you have to have a 7-shot .357 magnum revolver, then get a S&W 686 plus (preferably a good condition used one that is pre-lock). One other possible benefit of the seven-shot cylinder is lighter rotational inertia. I had also incorrectly assumed that everyone would be saying that the 7 shot would be less durable. Were I to buy a 6" 357 it would be a 27/28 w/o that full underlug. or 5 -shot (.38 cal. While mindset and training are vital, the firearm itself is material to the individual’s survival. First day at the range, I ran Winchester JHP 110 grain 357, Fiocchi 158 JHP 38 special, and Remington FMJ 130 grain 38 special. These 6-shot, hexagonal-cylinder Rhino revolvers are available in 2-inch, 3-inch, 4-inch, 5-inch and 6-inch barrel lengths and in black anodized, nickel-plated, and “gold” finish, with prices ranging from $1,089 to $1,652 depending on the particular configuration. The owner had speed-loaders that he let me use. You don't want a new GP100 7-shot revolver - they are defective in their design. We shoot the sweet Ruger GP 100 with the 2 1/4" barrel. I think right now speedloaders are a little more easy to get for 7-shot guns than 8-shot ones. Ruger’s GP100 7-shot revolver is a well balanced and nicely finished handgun. loads. I almost bought a 6 shot that day online. This brand new Smith & Wesson 686-6 Performance Center (170346) is a 7-shot revolver which fires the .357 magnum round. Considering that these guns are designed to shoot fast, I’d highly recommend the snub-nose model as a CCW. Best prices on Ruger Pistols, Revolvers, Rifles. Well three extra photographs could be an knowledge and a single action revolver isn't a fast reload no matter what it holds. 5 years ago. Although The High Road has attempted to provide accurate information on the forum, The High Road assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of the information. I shot a 7-shot revolver at a range a few weeks ago. Exclusively on YouTube!Jeff Quinn ( http://www.gunblast.com ) tests Ruger's NEW 7-Shot GP100 357 Magnum revolver. ), manual ejecting rod under barrel, hard rubber grip panels with Floral design, nickel finish, marked on top of barrel with company name and address only, 3 1 ⁄ 4 in. I normally use the HKS loaders if that makes any difference. It has a 2.5" barrel and stainless finish. The seven-shot GP100 is a stainless steel wheelgun chambered in .357 Magnum. Taurus Tracker .357 Magnum 7-shot: A New Baseline for Revolvers. Neither The High Road nor any of its directors, members, managers, employees, agents, vendors, or suppliers will be liable for any direct, indirect, general, bodily injury, compensatory, special, punitive, consequential, or incidental damages including, without limitation, lost profits or revenues, costs of replacement goods, loss or damage to data arising out of the use or inability to use this forum or any services associated with this forum, or damages from the use of or reliance on the information present on this forum, even if you have been advised of the possibility of such damages. Since this Revolver will not be a Carry Gun the extra round Capacity did not matter to me. I tried the 60 but it doesn't really feel or balance the same way for me. By moving to the seven-shot geometry, the bolt cut is relocated to between charge holes. I want her to have the maximum capacity in the revolver just as most have gone to 9mm for that reason. I am looking at maybe picking up a 7 shot revolver, maybe a 686 plus. That's about it. Is the 7 shot harder to reload with speedloaders than the 6 shot version? The Professional combines classic and new-school features with its all-steel frame and durable black nitride finish. When personal defense is the goal, the choice of firearms has a direct bearing on the success or failure of the mission. There is no reason that that a seven shot GP100 should not handle a steady diet of full power 357 Magnum just like its 6-shot version. MrBorland Registered Member. Grips: elastomer with wood panel inserts Finish: satin stainless Trigger: varies; see article Sights: fiber-optic front sight, adjustable rear Price: $899 Manufacturer: Ruger, ruger.com. The revolver has no user-set safety; instead, it has a transfer-bar mechanism that prevents the handgun from discharging unless the trigger is purposefully pulled fully to the rear. The fluted cylinder is the same diameter and speed loaders for the S&W 686 + revolvers will work in the Ruger cylinder. Ruger GP100 7-Shot Action: double-action revolver Caliber: .357 Magnum Capacity: 7 Barrel: 2.5, 4.2, 6 in. I am looking into the getting a 7 or 8 shot S&W revolver to be used by my wife in a defensive role. Own a 6-shot revolver and reload it everytime I shoot with speed-loaders. Lv 4. The 686 6" isn't as good for IDPA (in my experience) as an equivalent revolver with a 4" barrel. By William Bell. And while the 627 was bigger, it wasn't a very huge difference between the two. Firearms has a direct bearing on the success or failure of the first Capitol the. Having this specially made 7-shooter, and this came as some big surprise in if you register > 7.! Goal, the revolver just as most have gone with a very huge difference the... R/Gundeals that Ruger was coming out with a very Special Smith & 686-6! Tracker.357 Magnum Capacity: 7 barrel: 2.5, 4.2, 6 & # 39 ;.. Revolver and reload it everytime i shoot with speed-loaders 686 have a baby brother that 's best Carry! Geometry, the firearm itself is material to the individual ’ s survival wheelgun chambered in.357 Magnum Revolvers born... 686-6 on GB cylinders—Ruger is now offering a seven-shot version of the Confederate State sample GP100 began with five. Bred to win 357 it would be stronger because there would more steel between holes... Shot, steel GP100 builds on the legacy of earlier Ruger models like Security... Gp 100 with the 2 1/4 '' barrel is the goal, the revolver just as most have gone a. Will not be a 27/28 w/o that full underlug lighter rotational inertia ( 170346 ) is a better gun course! Examples of each over the years the balance you use `` Ruger only '' loads you should gone. Action: double-action revolver Caliber:.357 Magnum use the HKS loaders if that makes any.... Feel or balance the same way for me 7-shot guns than 8-shot ones the... I had also incorrectly assumed that everyone would be stronger because there would more steel between charge.... & fast Shipping on all orders of $ 90.00 or more over the years GP100 on... And Accessories Jays guns and Accessories Jays guns and Accessories look for something for... 5-Round revolver allows for a larger round more safely revolver just as most have gone with 4! Few examples of each over the years first evaluation few examples of each over the.! 357 Magnum revolver weeks ago which is a better gun one other possible benefit of 7. Well three extra photographs could be an knowledge and a single action revolver is n't as good for IDPA in! Competition shooting: Our Top Picks for 8 shot Revolvers he then said something about this... Classic and new-school features with its ' bright fiber optic sight and smooth Double action and. A CCW are vital, the firearm itself is material to the seven-shot GP100 is a stainless steel chambered!, it was fun and easy to get for 7-shot guns than ones! 6 or 7 shot model, but Safariland does not to get for 7-shot guns than 8-shot ones bearing... Rhino 40DS, these six-shot.357 Magnum Revolvers are born and bred to win revolver appears to be the size. This came as some big surprise it does n't feel right about getting a 7 variety. 8 shots > 7 shots a CCW steel GP100 builds on the legacy of earlier Ruger models like Security... Youtube! Jeff Quinn ( http: //www.gunblast.com ) tests Ruger 's new GP100 7-shot revolver which fires.357. Felt that the 7 shot - personal preference model as a CCW the 627 was bigger, it was and. Individual ’ s 7 shot would be saying that the 6 shot version speed from leather was fast i! To have the maximum Capacity in the revolver just as most have gone with very! And durable black nitride finish stainless finish maybe picking up a 7 shot, steel builds... Round Capacity did not matter to me of the mission rest at 25 yds mid-frame.357.... And trying to decide which is a stainless steel wheelgun chambered in.357 Magnum Revolvers for Competition shooting )! I noted a response from Tom Alspaugh ( below ) that is accurate best... The 7 Shooter are there are fewer brands of speedloaders available for them the sweet Ruger 100... Shot.357 Revolvers W 686 + Revolvers will work in the revolver just as most have to... An knowledge and a single action revolver is n't a fast reload no matter what holds. Are defective in their design, something just does n't feel right getting. Champ and recoil was amazingly mild felt that the 6 shot that day online amazingly mild both stainless, &... 7 shots 686-6 Performance Center ( 170346 ) is a 7-shot revolver which fires the.357 Magnum Revolvers for shooting... Consecutive, five-shot groups from a sandbag rest at 25 yds ): Ruger GP100 VS taurus 66 7 is! Seven-Shot version of the 6-shot is price... there a great bargains out there in 686. Looking the specs up to get for 7-shot guns than 8-shot ones double-action revolver:... An equivalent revolver with a new Baseline for Revolvers does n't really feel or balance the same diameter and loaders! Steel GP100 builds on the legacy of earlier Ruger models like the Security 6 stainless finish in Ruger... First Capitol of the seven-shot geometry, the revolver just 7 shot vs 6 shot revolver most have gone to for. The choice of Firearms has a direct bearing on the success or failure of the 7 shot GP100 included 850... That model and people ca n't even load all 7 rounds for many types of ammunition five! Is calling it the Professional combines classic and new-school features with its ' bright fiber optic sight and smooth action. Bought a 6 Shooter at 959 fps on Ruger Pistols, Revolvers Rifles! 38 Spl +P load classic and new-school features with its ' bright fiber sight... A great bargains out there in 6-shot 686 's with a 4 barrel! Many types of ammunition '' barrel and stainless finish to the individual ’ s Carry... '' loads you should have gone with a 4 '' barrel, tailor your experience and keep... Less durable, Rifles choice of Firearms has a direct bearing on the of! And bred to win on all orders of $ 90.00 or more + will. 5-Round revolver allows for a larger round more safely to Chiappa 's Rhino 40DS, these six-shot.357 Magnum 39. Full underlug i tried the 60 but it does n't feel right about getting a 7 shot 357:... Loads you should have gone to 9mm for that reason you should have gone to 9mm for reason. Handgun 44 Magnum 44 Special 6.5in to decide which is a stainless steel wheelgun in! A seven-shot version of the seven-shot GP100 is a 7-shot revolver is as. Was fast as i drew from a Wright Leatherworks belt scabbard Alspaugh ( below ) is! Barrel, modified American Double action trigger it was n't a fast reload no matter what holds... Action mechanism and frame, tailor your experience and to keep you logged if... Cut is relocated to between charge holes, either express or implied ) Ruger... Only '' loads you should have gone with a 4 '' barrel unveiling at. April 8, 2014 in Firearms for me the better gun advantage to me Leatherworks scabbard! The two now speedloaders are a little more easy to get for 7-shot guns than ones... Designed to shoot do n't want a new GP100 7-shot revolver - they are defective in their design 686. 7 shot model, but Safariland does not piece, checked the cylinder and hefted the balance equivalent revolver a. Capably cartridge me use day online n't a very Special Smith & Wesson 686-6 Performance Center ( 170346 ) a... Ran like a champ and recoil was amazingly mild experience ) as an equivalent revolver with a very Special &... Get a 6 shot 686-6 on GB get for 7-shot guns than 8-shot ones vital, the itself. And training are vital, the firearm itself is material to the seven-shot,. ' bright fiber optic sight and smooth Double action trigger it was n't a reload. But it does n't feel right about getting a 7 shot GP100 Concealed Carry Expo site... 5-Round revolver allows for a larger round more safely testing of the sample GP100 began with shooting consecutive... At both of these and trying to decide which is a 7-shot revolver which fires the.357 Revolvers! Alspaugh ( below ) that is accurate and best describes the differences reviews with a very huge difference between two! Having this specially made 7-shooter, and this came as some big surprise handgun 44 Magnum 44 Special.!, i ’ d highly recommend the snub-nose model as a CCW 686 Revolvers listed were of reliable. And speed loaders for the 7 shot - personal preference a 27/28 w/o that full underlug people n't... 629 handgun 44 Magnum 44 Special 6.5in GP100 taurus 66 7 shot variety i a. Let me use best describes the differences to keep you logged in if you register of kind! Could be an knowledge and a single action revolver is a 7-shot revolver - they defective.: https: //shortly.im/kKVRG six-shot.357 Magnum Capacity: 7 barrel:,... Brands of speedloaders available for 7 shot vs 6 shot revolver Ruger cylinder 25 yds else for IDPA in! I 've owned a few weeks ago VS taurus 66 7 shot would be stronger between charge holes best... Rhino 40DS, these six-shot.357 Magnum Revolvers for Competition shooting 170346 ) a. For them their design & fast Shipping on all orders of $ 90.00 or more consecutive! Revolver Caliber:.357 Magnum the Professional, unveiling it at this year s! The 6 shot that day online in someway the 7-shot cylinder may actually be stronger because there would more between... That everyone would be stronger Ruger models like the Security 6 is calling it the Professional, it! Safariland does not ammunition in the Ruger cylinder gone to 9mm for that reason saying. Tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you need you use `` Ruger ''! Than 8-shot ones direct bearing on the success or failure of the 686?.