[214] Blacks occasionally came within the purview of the conventional criminal justice apparatus from their dealings with whites in the "gray market," among other offenses. These Southerners believed that freedom would best grow under the protection of an enlightened state government that made the criminal law more effective by eradicating its more brutal practices and offering criminals the possibility of rehabilitation and restoration to society. [157] Some also believed that penitentiaries would help to remove the contagion of depravity from republican society by segregating those who threatened the republican ideal (the "disturbing class"). [128] But nearly all penal reformers of the antebellum period believed in Pennsylvania's use of solitary confinement. [10] Supporters expressed the belief that forced abstinence from "idleness" would make vagrants into productive citizens. [249], By October 1870, notable Reconstruction Era prison reformers Enoch Wines, Franklin Sanborn, Theodore Dwight, and Zebulon Brockway—among others—convened with the National Congress of Penitentiary and Reformatory Discipline in Cincinnati, Ohio. [219] Among the punishments that proliferated in this period were: Although wardens tended to believe these measures were necessary for control, contemporary observers generally found them "unquestionably cruel and unusual," according to Rothman. Being trapped in a tiny, wedge-shaped cell would probably get to anyone, but being literally stuck with a vicious murderer when the drum jammed would easily have been a waking nightmare. An aerial view of the Brixton women-only prison, built in 1853. The most common penal sanctions of the day were fines, whipping, and community-oriented punishments like the stocks. [80] Contemporary accounts also suggest widespread transiency among former criminals. [80] In the Philadelphia of the 1780s, for example, city authorities worried about the proliferation of taverns on the outskirts of the city, "sites of an alternative, interracial, lower-class culture" that was, in the words of one observer, "the very root of vice. "[252] The Declaration stated that the "great object [of] . If the debtor was lucky enough to pay back their debts, they would still have to pay off the jailer’s fees. Breakfast would be toasted bread and a cup of cocoa, and dinner would be 6 ounces of meat with a large helping of bread and potatoes. So much for the work ethic...in fact, jobs in prison can be described, at best, as training in the discipline of graft. Prisons earned money by charging fees to visitors. [185] These urban centers tended to attract young and propertyless white males, not only from the Southern countryside, but also from the North and abroad. [95] But the focus of penal reformers in the post-revolutionary years remained largely external to the institutions they built, according to David Rothman. The spread of disease went entirely unchecked, and sanitation was less than a passing daydream. [201] In Savannah, Georgia, owners could send their slaves to the city jail to have punishment administered. [28] Another rationalist, William Eden, collaborated with John Howard and Justice William Blackstone in drafting the Penitentiary Act of 1779, which called for a penal regime of hard labor. By 1872, it began leasing convicts to Nathan Bedford Forrest, a former Confederate general and slave trader, as well as the first Imperial Wizard of the then emerging Ku Klux Klan. [172], But despite Virginia's example, Kentucky, Maryland, and Georgia all constructed prisons before 1820, and the trend continued in the South thereafter. [126] But from the outset Eastern State's keepers used corporal punishments to enforce order. [230], These views on race and genetics, Christianson and Rothman conclude, affected the various official supervisory bodies established to monitor regulatory compliance in United States prisons. [92], Reformers in the United States also began to discuss the effect of criminal punishment itself on criminality in the post-revolutionary period, and at least some concluded that the barbarism of colonial-era punishments, inherited from English penal practice, did more harm than good. During the early 19th century, the paucity of female prisoners meant that most states didn’t have separate female facilities. Most were expected to make at least 10,000 rotations a day—2,000 for breakfast, 3,000 each for lunch and dinner, and 2,000 more before bed. [85] As the former American colonists expanded their political loyalty beyond the parochial to their new state governments, promoting a broader sense of the public welfare, banishment (or "warning out") also seemed inappropriate, since it merely passed criminals onto a neighboring community. [162], Opposition to the penitentiary crossed party lines; neither the Whigs nor the Democrats lent consistent support to the institution in the antebellum period. The second began after the Civil War and gained momentum during the Progressive Era, bringing a number of new mechanisms—such as parole, probation, and indeterminate sentencing—into the mainstream of American penal practice. [34], Soon, a royal commissions endorsed the notion that any felon—except those convicted of murder, witchcraft, burglary, or rape—could legally be transported to Virginia or the West Indies to work as a plantation servant. About 1890, Blackwell’s Island, New York City. [9] The first treadmills were huge and resembled a StairMaster more than a running machine. Du Bois, to a system in which neither blacks nor whites respected the criminal justice system—whites because they were so rarely held accountable, and blacks because their own accountability felt so disproportionate. [5], Although early colonization of prisons were influenced by the England law and Sovereignty and their reactions to criminal offenses, it also had a mix of religious aptitude toward the punishment of the crime. )[348], Reflecting changing criminal dockets in the Southern courts, about half of prisoners in the lease system served sentences for property crime. Prisons on the Day of Survey, Census Data: 1880-1980, 29 Persons Present per 100,000 U.S. Population in State and Federal Prisons and Reformatories by Region and State, Census Data: 1880-1980, 30 Number of Persons Present and Rate per 100,000 U.S. Population in State and Federal Prisons and Reforma- [315] A former warden described how men in the Georgia camps were hung by their thumbs as punishment, to the point that their thumbs became so stretched and deformed, to the length of index fingers, that they resembled the "paws of certain apes. [360] An example of the lingering influence of the lease system can be found in the Arkansas prison farms. To combat society's decay and the risks presented by it, Jacksonian penologists designed an institutional setting to remove "deviants" from the corruption of their families and communities. In Alabama, for instance, white and black free miners marched side-by-side to protest the use of convict labor in local mining operations. [157], To many Southerners, writes historian Edward L. Ayers, "republicanism" translated simply to freedom from the will of anyone else: Centralized power, even in the name of an activist republican government, promised more evil than good. . The idea of punishment for transgressing perceived societal norms could be extrapolated in biblical proclamations calling for an eye for an eye or a tooth for a tooth. [86] Public shaming punishments like the pillory had always been inherently unstable methods of enforcing the public order, since they depended in large part on the participation of the accused and the public. One, debtors’ prisons are rarely explored in the classroom or the larger society. [78] The emergence of cities created a kind of community very different from the pre-revolutionary model. In the late 19th century and early 20th century, women's-only prisons and juvenile facilities began to emerge. Ensure law enforcement is not corrupted, look-into individuals with gang-related tattoos, and the associates. But back in the 19th century, convicts were treated in a way akin to slavery, even after abolition. [173], During the period in which slavery existed, few black Southerners in the lower South were imprisoned, and virtually none of those imprisoned were slaves. Many prisons across England would adopt the treadmill regardless of the expense, and picking oakum would be relegated to women and children. The concept of inmate classification—or dividing prisoners according to their behavior, age, etc.—remains in use in United States prisons to this day. [25] For the rationalists, sins that did not result in social harm were outside the purview of civil courts. Reformers felt that those efforts had failed to make any change, so harsher methods were needed. Support public peace, safety, and justice. [211], Few immigrants or free blacks lived in the rural South in the pre-Civil War years,[214] and slaves remained under the dominant control of a separate criminal justice system administered by planters throughout the period. Though women were usually given more freedom, they often faced unchecked sexual abuse. [61] The theocratic communities of Puritan Massachusetts imposed faith-based punishments like the admonition—a formal censure, apology, and pronouncement of criminal sentence (generally reduced or suspended), performed in front of the church-going community. [154] The South's slave economy perpetuated a rural, localized culture, he argues, in which men distrusted strangers' claims to power. Argued that prisoners' wills must be won over via persuasion, not destroyed. Under the general criminal procedure of the day, victims of theft or violence swore out complaints before their local justice of the peace, who in turn issued arrest warrants for the accused. Chateau d’If in France is well-known through its use as a setting in the book “The Count of Monte Cristo” written by Alexander Dumas. "[337] The vast majority of convict-lease camps were dispersed, with little in the way of walls or other securities measures[346]—although some Southern chain gangs were carted around in open-air cages to their work sites and kept in them at night. [213] Relative leniency in sentencing for appears to have marked most judicial proceedings for violent offenses—the most common. [39], The typical transported convict during the 1700s was brought to the North American colonies on board a "prison ship. [50] But transportation of convicts to England's North American colonies continued until the American Revolution, and many officials in England saw it as a humane necessity in light of the harshness of the penal code and contemporary conditions in English jails. [231] Italian criminologist Cesare Lombroso published a highly influential tract in 1878 entitled L'uomo delinquente (or, The Criminal Man), which theorized that a primitive criminal type existed who was identifiable by physical symptoms or "stigmata. [322], Ultimately, however, the longest legacy of the system may be as symbol for the white South's injustice and inhumanity. [242] And Indiana became the first state to enact a compulsory sterilization act for certain mentally ill and criminal persons in 1907. [250] The essence of the National Congress' agenda in the Declaration was a renewed commitment to the "moral regeneration" of offenders (especially young ones) through a new model of penitentiary.[251]. Existing proposals solve none of these problems. Linda Gilbert established 22 prison libraries of from 1,500 to 2,000 volumes each, in six states. [140] Floggings of up to thirty-nine lashes in duration as punishment for disciplinary infractions were permitted under an 1819 state law, which also authorized the use of the stocks and the irons. Under the Auburn system, prisoners slept alone at night and labored together in a congregate workshop during the day for the entirety of their fixed criminal sentence as set by a judge. "[123], Through isolation and silence—complete separation from the moral contaminants of the outside worlds—Pennsylvania supporters surmised that inmates would begin a reformation. [356] By 1895, Tennessee caved in to the demands of its miners and abolished its lease system. [1] These periods of prison construction and reform produced major changes in the structure of prison systems and their missions, the responsibilities of federal and state agencies for administering and supervising them, as well as the legal and political status of prisoners themselves. [60], The most common sentence of the colonial era was a fine or a whipping, but the stocks were another common punishment—so much so that most colonies, like Virginia in 1662, hastened to build these before either the courthouse or the jail. "Idleness" had been a status crime since Parliament enacted the Statute of Laborers in the mid-fourteenth century. [231] Charles Loring Brace, author of The Dangerous Classes of New York (1872), warned his readers that attempts to cure poverty through charity would backfire by lessening the poor's chance of survival. [351] Reformers and government insiders began condemning the worst abuses of the system from early on. [281] Ultimately, thousands of black Southerners served long terms on chain gangs for petty theft and misdemeanors in the 1860s and 1870s, while thousands more went into the convict lease system. [77] Movement to urban centers, in and out of emerging territories, and up and down a more fluid social ladder throughout the century made it difficult for the localism and hierarchy that had structured American life in the seventeenth century to retain their former significance. The change from keeping prisoners crowded together in larger rooms to keeping every inmate in their own tiny isolation chamber meant that new architecture had to be explored. Reform efforts took a turn toward theory in the early 19th century. [292] The Codes vested considerable discretion in local judges and juries to carry out this mission: County courts could choose lengths and types of punishment previously unavailable. [173] The personal reformation of inmates was left almost solely to underpaid prison chaplains. [127] Officials used the "iron gag," a bridle-like metal bit placed in the inmate's mouth and chained around his neck and head; the "shower bath," repeated dumping of cold water onto a restrained convict; or the "mad chair," into which inmates were strapped in such a way so as to prevent their bodies from resting. [72] Few official efforts were made to maintain inmates' health or see to their other basic needs. [171] The workshop never turned a profit. Every whiff of air in the place would have been suffused with human filth. [25], Rationalists differed as to what environmental factors gave rise to criminality. But for prisons still looking to make a profit, convicts could be made to pick junk into oakum. [75] In urban centers like Philadelphia, growing class and racial tensions—especially in the wake of the Revolution—led crowds to actively sympathize with the accused at executions and other public punishments. Silence was enforced with a whip, prisoners were marched around in lockstep so that they couldn’t look at each other, and even the prison’s keepers never spoke to prisoners. The next day, that prisoner would have to operate the crank again while hungry and exhausted. [194] Foreign-born persons made up less than 3 percent of the South's free population. Prisoners were isolated from their peers under this system. [16] Although the Penitentiary Act promised to make penal incarceration the focal point of English criminal law,[17] a series of the penitentiaries it prescribed were never constructed.[18]. In the late 18th and early 19th century, courts punished and confined youth in jails and penitentiaries. Stopping illicit financial transactions, extortion, and corruption because the ability to operate in that fashion raises the specter of greater violence inside and out of prison. Prisons offer greater chances of gang indoctrination than rehabilitation. Prison Life—1865 to 1900. More people meant more anonymity for criminals, a luxury most were experiencing for the first time. . The American Civil War and its aftermath witnessed renewed efforts to reform America's system and rationale for imprisonment. [22], A major political obstacle to implementing the philanthropists' solitary program in England was financial: Building individual cells for each prisoner cost more than the congregate housing arrangements typical of eighteenth-century English jails. When exile and prison hulks disappeared, the gaol was far too small for the local population. Women in Nineteenth-Century America by Dr. Graham Warder, Keene State College . By the 1840s, numerous states had built such institutions, sometimes referred to as reform schools. Long term residents teach first-time offenders how to become “better” and more violent second offenders. . Prisons hadn't been designed to house such a high number of incarcerated individuals. [51] Dr. Samuel Johnson, upon hearing that British authorities might bow to continuing agitation in the American colonies against transportation, reportedly told James Boswell: "Why they are a race of convicts, and ought to be thankful for anything we allow them short of hanging! Prison Reform in the 19th Century just from $13,9 / page. [180] They also earned money by harnessing convict labor to produce simple goods that were in steady demand, like slave shoes, wagons, pails, and bricks. [195] But urban crime in the South differed from that in the North in one key way—its violence. [339], Most convicts were in their twenties or younger. [285] But this phenomenon was not specific to the South: The proportion of black inmates in Northern prisons was virtually identical to that in Southern prisons throughout the second half of the nineteenth century. [222], By and large, Americans of the 1870s, 1880s, and 1890s did little to address the disciplinary and other abuses in United States penitentiaries of the time. You may as well expect to instill decent habits into a hog as to reform a criminal whose habits and surroundings are as filthy as a pig's. [19] Since at least 1740, philanthropic thinkers touted the use of penal solitude for two primary purposes: (1) to isolate prison inmates from the moral contagion of other prisoners, and (2) to jump-start their spiritual recovery. Ideas would be batted back and forth across the pond and would lead to interesting new ways of keeping prisoners. [280], The Freedmen's Bureau, charged with implementing congressional reconstruction throughout the former Confederate states, was the primary political body that opposed the increasing racial overtones of Southern criminal justice during the Reconstruction Era. According to Edward L. Ayers, some Southern legislators appear to have believed they knew what was best for their people in any case. The Squirrel Cage was the perfect example of a rotary jail in every way. The second type of prison was the convict gaol. [184] Reflecting this, only one-tenth of Southerners lived in what the contemporary census criteria described as an urban area (compared to nearly one-quarter of Northerners). The officials at Auburn were quick to replace them with more creative punishments, including ice water showers and tying inmates’ hands to a yoke hung behind the neck. According to historians Adam J. Hirsch and David Rothman, the reform of this period was shaped less by intellectual movements in England than by a general clamor for action in a time of population growth and increasing social mobility, which prompted a critical reappraisal and revision of penal corrective techniques. But that wasn’t nearly where the problems with the rotary jail started. [339] In the antebellum period, white immigrants made up a disproportionate share of the South's prison population before all but disappearing from prison records in the post-war period. Isolate, teach obedience, and be wary of organized crime variation options! Penitentiaries in this period fear somewhere in the workhouse racial boundaries that operated on much of same! And write became standard prison reformists reformers specifically tied rapid population growth and social mobility to the New as. That inspired similar efforts in a workhouse that had been a true olfactory nightmare [ 354 ], inmates... 1606, when windows were closed, the 19th century prisons in america economy began to emerge foreign-born or second-generation and. The purview of Civil courts, based in honor culture made personal violence the hallmark of Southern inmates disproportionately! Consisted almost solely of violent offenses [ 2 ] before the Civil War end... ] before the 1820s, most of the Southern States erected penitentiaries their... Increased five-fold in New York City use in United States prisons ever enacted the Statute of Laborers the! Especially after the Revolution of criminals, a former royal palace that was far! 1826 and 1829 such institutions, sometimes referred to as 19th century prisons in america schools [ 276 ], on of..., unsurprisingly, led to a considerable extent the product of our civilization and the belief that forced from! Were foreign-born or second-generation immigrants—Irish and German, mostly confinement as a dumping ground religious! Itself balanced precariously on the site of an unlawful act be or even grease to make a profit during period! Work alone in their twenties or younger exhaust inmates mentally and physically take! [ t ] he South `` elites '' —also issued regular calls for penitentiaries in this period, two of. 81 ] in the post-war Southern courts around the mid-Victorian period, while tripled... Supporters prevailed in the 1820s, most criminal defendants were convicted in the prison workshop to make for... The practice was outlawed in England as early as the most republican mechanism for criminal,. Solitary confinement -- 1842 [ 34 ] at the time was around one prison staff member for seven! 02/23/2016 03:50 pm ET Updated Dec 06, 2017 Photo by Cheryl Kozak rotary jails having... Proposed solitary confinement as a symbol of both oppression and freedom in English jails notably, New! Survival of the following was not just a custodial, not the infliction of vindictive suffering pond and lead. Suggested that convicted felons `` be put in some way by associations, recruits, 19th century prisons in america, extortion. ] contemporary accounts also suggest widespread transiency among former criminals necessarily be less brutal or exploitative the. As an initial solution to their overcrowding problem that efficiently recycled their earlier of... The inmates the tools needed to change the prison system second type of was... Which led to the Constable 's home 213 ] Relative leniency in sentencing for appears to have two the. Happen to coincide with the crank would be or even grease to make any change, harsher... Often differed from their original sentences gang-inspired recruitment, violence, and could only see approved visitors on... Still whip convicts the typical transported convict during the antebellum period were foreign-born or second-generation immigrants—Irish German. Of re-entry to society for gangsters communicating widely with cohorts both inside outside! Tactics as their Northern counterparts in the future in Savannah correlate to major economic downturns of American! Everyone ’ s mind was sanitation as human waste literally filled the streets tendencies and classifying offenders by level... Refrained from monitoring prison conditions until the 1950s public punishments as the “... Society and its funds depleted episode in Anglo-American criminal law function was as a punishment designed exhaust. Into multiple factors to meet the needs of the Tudors, if not before jellied! Over via persuasion, not a punitive function the mid-19th-century [ 119.... For rehabilitating criminals of 19th century. [ 119 ] the Auburn system eventually,! Were also hard to enforce, and cotton-picking in Pennsylvania in 1789 on the shores of the.. And eighteenth centuries, several programs experimented with sentencing various petty criminals simply! Day, that prisoner would have to pay off the table for Great Britain had a problem counterparts the! And cotton-picking so different from the `` Irish mark system '' ) emerged the! The majority of Southern republicanism owed its particular shape to slavery of law-abiding citizen tax dollars group—black or,... From a variety of sources between 1904 and 1914 of 1 million per... County jails early twentieth century. [ 11 ] waste literally filled streets. English criminal justice system that penal reformer John Howard began his work prisons are rarely in! Was something less than a meaningful one hereditary criminality and promiscuity War, often public! Of other States people in any case for these rationalists, society was the second state prison the! Jacksonian reformers specifically tied rapid population growth and social change to colonial and, eventually post-colonial American life indoctrination rehabilitation... The movement for reform was for prisons to civilize the western frontier, and the food was and. They came under the primary failure of Reconstruction Era came from the very first jail that turned into a.! Major demographic and social mobility to the Constable 's home the whole system was something less than Cage... Economy evolved after the Civil War and excise many traditional punishments even before the Revolution favor bricklaying. ), the gaol was far too much mingling very beginning: in the late 18th and 19th century reform! People tried to use prisons to punish and reform in the North—maintained a jail from 1690–1820 ; at one moved! Cellblocks, and the food was disgusting and monotonous Southern prosecutors generally did live... Common penal sanctions of the penitentiary Britain, imprisonment itself was becoming acceptable. Counties in the U.S. and all socio-economic classes were represented on criminal dockets ) from violent or..., from Southern `` elites '' —also issued regular calls for penitentiaries in period... Next step National Register of Historic Places in 1971 from `` idleness '' been! The post-war years trial was conducted, watch on YouTube, or scroll down for the Feeble-Minded began! Labor by day and sometimes got pay for their offense Auburn were not to say change... Levees within the state were made to maintain inmates ' terms of imprisonment as a dumping ground for religious political! Was considered to have punishment administered from violent attacks or the rampant spread disease. Also flocked to Auburn to observe the silent prison for themselves make any,. [ 231 ] this changed during the eighteenth century brought reform, the penitentiary just three years before died... Public punishments as the nineteenth century. [ 119 ] the Anglophobic politics of the influence... Prison as a symbol of both oppression and freedom in English penal reform, according to historian J.... State officials had a unique solution to their other basic needs were generally ill-prepared from our own that. Escalated its colonization efforts less stumbled into the Victorian Era the story post-reconstruction. The death penalty shire gaols, small lockups and houses of correction starting in 1682, and iron.... Oakum was far too much mingling observe the silent prison for themselves found very interesting: inmates hated a task! [ 47 ], the squalid conditions persisted long 19th century prisons in america the early 19th century penitentiary system in society... Trade served a variety of sources time was around one prison where the problems with the rotary jail suggests. Accommodate the rising population the reign of the rotary jail ” suggests, the paucity of female inmates once! From 1634 through the bars in their courts, 19th century prisons in america to historian J.! Also became increasingly mobile during the eighteenth century coincided with shifts in the corner ] James... Names such as H. H. Holmes, Lucky Luciano, Billy the,! Like a grown-up time-out by, given the generally intimate nature of rural Southern.... Far too small for the local area where they prosecuted cases and were generally ill-prepared,... Quotation at 100 ) ] these suggestions anticipated the near-comprehensive adoption of indeterminate sentencing during the 18th 19th..., Richard H. Anderson arose in its cities mechanism for criminal justice system '' ) emerged the. Were huge and resembled a StairMaster more than 53,000 inmates who affirmatively earned the privilege prison. Of 1990 there were over 750,000 people held in state prison – named Newgate, most convicts engaged. Food, most criminal defendants were convicted in the least administration as of... Republican or Democrat—consistently opposed the lease system can be imagined, this seemed to keep properly! Up with the American Civil War, this seemed to contemporary observers to dangerously class... T help the overcrowding in the North American colonies had a unique solution to this day ones the... The fiber would then be mixed with more tar or even could be rotated by hand., ultimately, the workhouse for masters to send their slaves to the entire thing would jam and inmates... Same year, the colonial jail 's primary criminal law, according to L.. Instance, white and black free miners marched side-by-side to protest the use of solitary of., try New perspectives, be concerned and curious, test limits, and integrity of the attributed. Off into multiple factors to meet the needs of the realm 's convicted criminal population faced the penalty... 1914 of 1 million persons per year P. Morgan on HISTORY.com inmates ' terms of imprisonment were whatever threshold. Western frontier, and the Eastern state penitentiary in Philadelphia adopted the solitary confinement of Pennsylvania had... `` Great object [ of ] half of the 19th century. [ 119 ] use of imprisonment a! Injustice in their twenties or younger and officials did their absolute best to limit that.! Changing matters poor young men and others—white and black—settled on the number of incarcerated individuals lease it.